The lack of a natural large animal model of cataractogenesis has limited our ability to investigate the development of opacity. The ovine cataract is a cortical cataract,
11 which is inherited as a dominant trait, appears at an early age and proceeds in a reproducible fashion over several months. This inherited ovine cataract provides a convenient model to research the biochemical changes in the lens as it becomes opaque, because a single lens is of sufficient size to carry out a whole range of biochemical and chemical tests.
Cortical cataracts in many species, including humans, have been associated with imbalances in ions and, in particular, calcium levels.
21 Further work is required to determine whether the high calcium concentrations found in the ovine cataract are generalized or localized to a particular part of the lens. The ovine cataract has also displayed increased degradation of lens proteins, which is a characteristic feature of cortical cataracts.
22 The production of degraded proteins suggests there is a possible role for the calcium-dependent proteases or calpains in cataract development. Calpains have been found in the lenses from many species.
2 23 24 25 The ovine lens appears similar to the lenses of other species in that calpain II is the dominant calpain isoform followed by lower levels of calpain I activity.
25 The lens-specific calpain isoform, Lp82, has been reported in young rats,
18 mice,
26 and cattle.
27 Calpain is involved in regulating the proteolysis of several proteins that are required for the normal development of a lens, including crystallins,
14 28 29 connexins,
30 and major intrinsic protein.
31 The rise in calcium levels observed in cataractogenesis may lead to the overactivation of calpain and the degradation of lens proteins. For example, the profile of spectrin breakdown in the lenses with cataracts, particularly bands at 145 and 150 kDa, are indicative of calpain proteolysis
6 32 33 compared with normal lenses, which have an abundant 120kDa breakdown typical of caspase 3 proteolytic activity. The decline in extractable calpain activity with progression of the cataract is an indication of its activation and subsequent autolysis. A similar, although more pronounced pattern is seen for calpain I in postmortem meat.
34
If calpain proteolysis is a cause of ovine cataract, then inhibition of calpain may prevent or retard any cataract progression. SJA6017, a cell-permeable peptide aldehyde, has been reported to be effective in preventing opacities in cultured rat and pig lenses,
35 36 and in slowing induced cataracts in rats.
37 In the present study, SJA6017 was applied as an eyedrop to the left eye of sheep over a 4-month period. The inhibitor appeared to slow the progression of cataractogenesis in the first month (Wilcoxon signed rank test,
P < 0.01), but, after this period, both lenses progressed at similar rates
(Fig. 9) . This is consistent with in vitro studies in which SJA6017 was only partially effective in reducing cataract formation in lens culture systems.
35 In vivo studies have shown the systemic uptake of SJA6017 was initially able to slow cataract formation in selenite-induced cataracts in rats.
37 The SJA6017 effect was temporary, and the cataracts progressed to the mature stage. The limited effectiveness of SJA6017 may be because of its low concentration in lens. The levels obtained in these reported experiments were <10 nM, and are well below the IC
50 of 80 nM.
37 Similar results were obtained in the lens of SJA6017 peritoneally injected rats, where SJA6017 concentrations were measured at 30 nM.
37 It is possible that any SJA6017 reaching the lens becomes localized in the lens epithelium and the cortex, where most of the calpain II activity resides in rat lens.
18
In conclusion, this study has characterized the calpains in ovine lens and provided evidence that calpains have a role in the inherited ovine cataract. Topical application of a calpain inhibitor has been shown to slow but not prevent cataractogenesis in sheep, which inherit cataracts. Further research is continuing to determine the suitability of this naturally inherited ovine cataract as a model for cataract formation in humans.
The authors thank Steve Heap (veterinary ophthalmologist, McMaster & Heap Veterinary Practice, Christchurch, NZ) for his technical assistance in determining the stage of cataracts in the sheep eyes; and Hong Ma (Integrative Biosciences, OHSU, Portland, OR) for kindly supplying the Lp82 antibody.