Twenty-four children between the ages of 2 and 7 years (mean and median = 4.7; SD = 1.3) underwent full ophthalmic examination including acuity (Allen or Snellen optotypes), cycloplegic refraction, assessment of eye alignment, fundus examination, and stereo acuity, if they were cooperative with the Titmus test. The definition of amblyopia followed modified guidelines of the Amblyopia Treatment Study.
25 Amblyopia was defined as an interocular acuity difference of 3 or more log minimum angle of resolution (logMAR) related to strabismus and/or anisometropia, with an otherwise normal eye examination. Anisometropic amblyopia was defined as amblyopia in the presence of an interocular refractive difference of 0.50 D or greater in spherical equivalent or a 1.50-D or greater difference in astigmatism in any meridian (meridional amblyopia). All anisometropic amblyopes had microtropia, defined as an abnormality of binocularity in which there is a heterotropia less than 10 prism D in conjunction with reduced stereoacuity.
Strabismus was defined as any heterotropia at distance and/or near fixation of 10 prism D or more. Accommodative esotropia was defined as any strabismus in which horizontal alignment was established to within 10 prism D with spectacles (may include bifocals). Nonaccommodative esotropia was defined as heterotropia of 10 prism D or more with full hyperopic correction and bifocals. Eleven healthy children (2–8 years of age; mean, 5.4) with normal findings in an ophthalmic examination and 20/20 acuity served as control subjects.
Acuity was measured at a 20-foot distance (B-VAT II Acuity Tester; Mentor, Norwell, MA), with appropriate optical correction determined by cycloplegic refraction. Optotypes were whole-line Allen or Snellen targets, or isolated optotypes if the subject was uncooperative with whole-line testing. Viewing distance was reduced for subjects unable to discriminate the 20/200 optotype and then acuity was scaled appropriately. All acuities were transformed into logMAR (e.g., 0.0 = 20/20, and 1.0 = 20/200).
All amblyopes were treated with full-time monocular occlusion during waking hours for 1 week per year of age. All testing was performed with the subject wearing full optical correction. None of the subjects had the optical correction changed or had surgery during treatment. Full-time occlusion was repeated up to three times until the best acuity was achieved. Thereafter, part-time patching (4–6 h/d for 4–7 d/wk) was used. Twenty-one subjects returned for their first scheduled visit (mean, 70 days). Three subjects failed to return for follow-up. Visual acuity outcome in the amblyopic eye was the best acuity recorded during an average 2.6-year follow-up. The patch was removed from the occluded eye for at least 3 hours before repeat VEP testing, to avoid short-term occlusion effects.
26
Stimuli were generated by a calibrated 12-bit video system (Venus; NeuroScientific Corp., Farmingdale, NY; no longer produced) and presented on a monitor that subtended 20° × 20° at 60 cm distance. Subjects wore optical correction and the untested eye was patched. All stimuli were of saturating contrast,
27 to offset the reduced contrast sensitivity of the amblyopic visual system while having little effect on the control eye.
19 20 21 Stimuli were contrast-reversing checkerboards (80% contrast, 1.4 Hz, 52 cd/m
2 mean luminance) of 163, 84, 42, and 18 arc min (spatial frequency was the fundamental frequency along the 45° diagonal). Additional stimuli were pattern-onset of sine wave gratings (99% contrast, 43 cd/m
2 mean luminance) of 0.5, 1, 2, and 4 cyc/deg presented for 200 ms followed by a blank screen for 800 ms at the same mean luminance. We chose these spatial frequencies because they generate a detectable VEP signal across all severity levels of amblyopia, and they overlap the spatial frequency tuning of cortical cells in monkey models of amblyopia.
4 Gratings were oriented horizontally and presented on large fields to minimize fixation and latent nystagmus artifact.
28 Assuming total axial length accounts for most ametropia,
29 retinal magnification alters the stimulus spatial frequency by a factor of 0.87 to 1.44 between the most hyperopic and myopic eyes.
Preparation of patients for VEPs followed International Society for Clinical Electrophysiology of Vision (ISCEV) guidelines,
30 using Oz as active, Cz as reference, and Pz as ground. Details of VEP recording, maturation, and scoring of waveforms are described elsewhere.
31 32 33 34 Briefly, check-reversal amplitude was the difference between the first major positive peak near 100 ms (P100) and the preceding negative peak. Pattern-onset P1 amplitude was the difference between the first major positive peak near 120 ms to the preceding negative peak (or baseline if absent). Pattern-onset negative peak (N)2 amplitude was the difference between the positive peak (P)1 and the major negative peak near 200 ms. Amplitudes were normalized to the largest response from the nonamblyopic eye, which reduce intersubject amplitude variation.
22
Statistical software (Systat, Inc., Richmond, CA) was used for all analyses. Analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) compared effects of discrete variables (e.g., amblyopic versus nonamblyopic eye, each spatial frequency), and the interaction of these variables on normalized amplitude after removing the variance associated with age and severity of amblyopia. Outcomes from the ANCOVA were (1) the main effect of eye tested, which indicated an overall change in normalized amplitudes between the amblyopic and nonamblyopic eyes after collapsing the data across spatial frequency and (2) the ANCOVA interaction, which indicated a change in response across spatial frequencies between the amblyopic and the nonamblyopic eyes. The Bonferroni test was used for multiple post hoc comparisons.
This research adhered to the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki. Guardians in this study provided informed consent after explanation of the nature and possible consequences of the study.