There is a paucity of information on the effect of acute ischemia on vasomotor function of the retinal microvasculature and the mechanism underlying development of the vascular pathophysiology is virtually unknown. Because retinal vascular disease is associated with ischemia and increased oxidative stress, it is imperative to investigate the effect of retinal ischemia on vasodilator function of retinal arterioles and to assess the possible role of oxygen-derived free radicals in vascular dysfunction. The salient findings of the present study demonstrate that exposure to elevated IOP for at least 90 minutes in the pig diminishes the ability of isolated retinal arterioles to dilate to bradykinin and to L-lactate, but not to sodium nitroprusside, after ischemia, and that pharmacological scavenging of superoxide anions preserves vasodilator function. Therefore, short-term retinal ischemia enhances oxidative stress, which subsequently compromises retinal endothelial function in terms of NO-mediated vasodilation. To the best of our knowledge, these results are the first evidence for a direct impact of elevated IOP-induced retinal ischemia on vasomotor function of retinal arterioles.
In the present study, we used an established in-vivo elevated IOP model
11 –15 to characterize the retinal microvascular dysfunction associated with ischemia and then used an in-vitro approach to elucidate the putative cellular/molecular mechanisms. Because pig and human retinas exhibit similar characteristics in neuroanatomy, immunology, and vascular reactivity,
23 –30 we used the pig as the experimental model. In regard to vascular function, we recently showed that dilations of isolated human retinal arterioles to pharmacological (bradykinin, adenosine, and endothelin-1) and physiological vasoactive stimuli (flow-induced vasodilation and pressure-induced myogenic tone) were comparable to the responses in pig retinal arterioles.
30 Importantly, at a mechanistic level, human and porcine retinal arterioles both elicited NO-mediated dilation to bradykinin and to increases in flow, as well as Rho kinase-dependent myogenic tone and constriction to endothelin-1 in a comparable manner. Retinal ischemia was produced in the present study by elevating and maintaining IOP (80–90 mm Hg) above the retinal perfusion pressure. Several recent studies have also used this model at similar levels of elevated IOP in the pig to study the effect of ischemia on neural/glial cells and on gene/protein expression in neural retina and retinal vessels. The results from those studies demonstrated that short-term ischemia (60 minutes to 2 hours) followed by reperfusion was sufficient to promote Müller cell gliosis
31 and loss of ganglion cells,
32,33 and to increase expression of inflammatory proteins (mitogen-activated protein kinases and tumor necrosis factor alpha) in neural and vascular retina.
34,35 Our findings further support use of the porcine model and provide direct evidence for the effect of acute retinal ischemia alone on retinal arteriolar function.
Accumulating evidence suggests that retinal ischemia due to incompetent flow regulation and/or abnormal vasomotor function initiates or participates in the pathogenesis of several retinal diseases, including retinal vascular occlusion, acute angle-closure glaucoma, and diabetic retinopathy.
1,36 Although experimental studies have shown that a brief episode of retinal hypoxic-ischemia in pigs can impair endothelium-mediated dilation to acetylcholine in the retinal circulation and reduce retinal blood flow,
4,5 the direct effect of ischemia on retinal arterioles and the underlying mechanisms responsible for this diminished vasodilator response are not completely understood. The lack of this basic information hampers our understanding of the development/progression of vascular abnormalities associated with retinal ischemia. Therefore, in the present study we used an isolated vessel approach
16,20,21,30,37 to directly characterize the vasomotor response of small retinal arterioles, the major regulators of retinal blood flow, after retinal ischemia under a defined environment. We first established the temporal effect of retinal ischemia on vasodilator function and found that 30 and 60 minutes of elevated IOP were insufficient to hinder dilation of retinal arterioles to endothelium-dependent NO-mediated agonist bradykinin. On the other hand, exposure to ischemia for 90 minutes led to significant reduction of vasodilation to bradykinin. Because endogenous tissue levels of bradykinin are increased during acute ischemia,
38,39 the release of this peptide might be important to blood flow regulation during inadequate supply of nutrients. Our current finding on the impairment of bradykinin-induced vasodilation may have clinical implication in the development of retinal vascular disease. Because vasodilation to endothelium-independent NO donor sodium nitroprusside was unaffected after all time periods of ischemia, it appears that acute retinal ischemia selectively impaired endothelial function. Interestingly, Hayreh and colleagues
40 –42 demonstrated narrowing of retinal vessels and irreversible damage of the neural retina (visual evoked response) after occlusion of the central retinal artery for at least 105 minutes in monkeys. The slight differences in retinal tolerance (105 minutes vs 90 minutes in the present study) may be related to species (monkey versus pig), ischemia model (direct arterial occlusion versus elevated IOP) or approach (in vivo versus in vitro assessment of retinal circulation). Nonetheless, these studies together support comparable time-dependent susceptibility of the retinal circulation to acute retinal ischemia. Although we did not examine the influence of reperfusion on vascular function, the temporal findings in our study are consistent with an earlier report that 90 minutes of retinal ischemia in the rat, but not 30 or 60 minutes, followed by reperfusion was required to cause sustained retinal edema.
43 Ischemia alone was not evaluated in this earlier study, but the 90 minutes of ischemia seems sufficient to elicit both functional and structural changes in the retinal microcirculation.
In addition to the reduction of bradykinin-induced NO-mediated dilation, acute retinal ischemia also reduced the dilation of retinal arterioles in response to the endogenous metabolic factor L-lactate. A responsive change in retinal arteriolar diameter to vasoactive metabolites is essential in terms of regulating retinal blood flow to match metabolic demands of the retinal tissue.
44 Lactate is a major product of retinal tissue metabolism that has been proposed to be an important signal for modulating retinal microvascular tone. The putative regulatory role of lactate is based on the observations in animal and human studies showing that intravitreal
45 and intravenous
46,47 administration of L-lactate, as well as exercise-induced hyperlactatemia,
48 evokes dilation of retinal arteries and increases retinal blood flow, respectively, in vivo. Similar to our earlier study, we used neutralized L-lactate to prevent the potential influence of pH on vascular tone. Our previous study showed that neutralized L-lactate caused endothelium-dependent NO-mediated dilation of porcine retinal arterioles.
21 The current findings on impaired vasodilation to bradykinin and L-lactate support the view that pathophysiological and physiological vasodilator agonists are susceptible to detrimental actions of acute 90-minute retinal ischemia in the context of impairing endothelium-dependent NO-mediated vasodilation.
A potential mechanism contributing to the ischemia-induced vascular dysfunction could be increased oxidative stress within the neuronal and/or vascular cells. It has been shown that reactive oxygen species can be increased in the retinal tissue during acute retinal ischemia
9 and elevated IOP.
49,50 Furthermore, an earlier study surmised that elevated IOP reduces NO-mediated increase in blood flow via enhanced production of reactive oxygen species leading to reduction of electroretinogram, based on the evidence that antioxidants in the absence but not presence of NO synthase blockade (nitro-L-arginine) preserved neuronal function.
49 However, it remains unclear whether ischemia elicits generation of reactive oxygen species within the retinal vasculature and subsequently affects vasomotor function. Reactive oxygen species such as superoxide anions can alter NO-mediated reactivity directly by inactivating NO
51 and/or inhibiting NO synthase activity.
52 Therefore, we investigated whether superoxide plays a role in vascular dysfunction. Our data support the idea of NO deficiency because the intravitreal administration of the membrane permeable superoxide dismutase mimetic TEMPOL before 90 minutes of elevated IOP preserved the postischemia dilation of isolated retinal arterioles to bradykinin. The salutary effect of TEMPOL seems to be specific because it did not affect resting basal tone or vasodilation to SNP. Further support for superoxide production was revealed with DHE staining showing that 90 minutes of retinal ischemia is capable of generating TEMPOL-sensitive superoxide in the vascular wall of retinal arterioles. These findings in the retinal vasculature extend previous evidence in vivo showing that free radical scavengers prevented ischemia (45 minutes)-induced increase in oxygen-derived free radical production in the rabbit retina and prevented neuronal dysfunction (loss of neuronal b wave during electroretinogram measurement).
50 Although the possible contribution of specific vascular oxidant enzymes to the impaired NO-mediated dilation remains unclear, our current data support the idea that increased oxidative stress within the vascular wall during acute retinal ischemia contributes to endothelium-dependent vasodilator dysfunction.
In conclusion, we have demonstrated for the first time that retinal ischemia elicited by 90-minute elevation of IOP impairs endothelium-dependent NO-mediated dilation of isolated porcine retinal arterioles. The mechanism underlying the inhibitory effect of retinal ischemia involves enhanced levels of superoxide in arterioles. This acute retinal ischemia model in the pig will be a useful tool to investigate the direct impact of ischemia on vascular reactivity in the retinal microcirculation. The results obtained from the present studies provide further knowledge toward our understanding of the pathogenesis of retinal vascular disease associated with acute retinal ischemia.
Supported by Scott & White Research Foundation (TWH), Retina Research Foundation (LK), NIH NEI R01EY018420 (TWH), the Scott & White Research Foundation Ophthalmic Vascular Research Program (LK), the Kruse Family Endowment Fund (LK), and NIH NEI K08EY016143 (RHR).
The authors thank Wenjuan Xu and Hongfang Liu for their expert technical assistance.