Abstract
Purpose.:
To determine the utility of polychromatic angiography (PCA) in the assessment of VEGF-induced blood retinal barrier (BRB) dysfunction in rabbits.
Methods.:
Twenty-six eyes of 24 Dutch Belted rabbits were injected intravitreally with 1.25 μg (group A, n = 5), 10 μg (group C, n = 7), or 4 μg (group B, n = 6; group D, n = 4; and group E, n = 4) of VEGF on day 0. Groups D and E were also injected intravitreally with 1.25 μg and 12.5 μg bevacizumab, respectively, on day 2. On days 0, 2, 4, 7, 11, and 14, PCA was performed using a contrast agent mixture composed of fluorescein sodium, indocyanine green, PCM102, and PCM107 and imaged with a modified fundus camera. PCA scores were based on detected leaking fluorophores.
Results.:
On day 7, there was a statistically significant difference between PCA scores of group A (0.6 ± 0.89) and both groups B (2.67 ± 1.37, P = 0.0154) and C (3.33 ± 0.52, P = 0.00085). There was also a statistically significant difference between groups B and E (PCA score 0.75 ± 0.96, P = 0.032) on day 7. On day 11, there was statistically significant difference between group C (1.80 ± 1.1) and both groups A (0, P = 0.021) and B (0.33 ± 0.52, P = 0.037).
Conclusions.:
A differential response to both increasing VEGF dose and administration of bevacizumab could be discerned using the PCA. PCA allowed stratification of VEGF-induced BRB dysfunction and inhibitory effects of bevacizumab therapy in the rabbit retina.
Presently, there are no clinical diagnostic tools to quantify blood-retinal barrier (BRB) dysfunction. Fluorescein angiography (FA) merely demonstrates the presence or absence of retinal vascular leakage. So, although it may provide a qualitative/descriptive assessment of the nature of leakage, it is not quantitative. Several efforts have been made to quantify fluorescein leakage either by measuring its accumulation in the vitreous cavity,
1,2 calculating the area of leakage,
3,4 or by estimating brightness intensity from photographs.
5 However, none of these techniques is widely used. Optical coherence tomography (OCT) can quantify retinal thickening, and reveal cyst formation and other gross morphological alterations resulting from imbalance in fluid ingress and egress from the retinal tissues,
6 but it does not directly quantify BRB dysfunction.
The feasibility of using fluorescinated dextrans of different molecular weights for angiographic evaluation of BRB dysfunction is well established in animals
7–13 and tested with promising results in humans.
14 The correlation between progression or regression of model pathologies and the size of leaking particles has also been demonstrated.
12,13 McNaught et al.
12 have shown that as laser-induced BRB dysfunction in rabbit healed, less of the larger molecular weight fluorescein-dextran particles leaked. In a monkey model of uveitis, Lightman et al.
13 found a gradual increase in the molecular weight of leaking fluorescein-dextran as the disease progressed. Using electron microscopy, these authors also found that vascular segments that leaked 70-KDa FITC-dextran had more severe pathological changes to the endothelial cell junctions compared with vascular segments that leaked 20-KDa FITC-dextran or 376-Da fluorescein, which showed no abnormalities.
Despite the correlation of molecular weight leakage to pathological processes and the potentially important diagnostic information it may provide, this diagnostic approach has not been widely used due to limitations, such as the poor signal intensity of fluorescinated dextrans, the low sensitivity of the older fundus cameras, and, most importantly, the need for a separate imaging session for each molecular weight.
With advances in a camera's fluorescence sensitivity and improved loading of dextrans with fluorophores of higher quantum yields, it has become feasible to overcome many of these limitations. Furthermore, simultaneous administration of multiple fluorophores with different excitation and emission spectra attached to dextrans of various sizes could provide a more practical clinical assessment of retinal vascular function.
In this study, we report a new angiographic technique to assess the size selective BRB permeability and to stratify dysfunction by using multiple fluorophores (conjugated and unconjugated) of different effective molecular weights. We term this new technique polychromatic angiography (PCA).
Bovine retinal endothelial cells (BRECs) were grown to confluence on fibronectin-coated filters with 0.4-μm pores (Transwell; Corning Costar, Acton, MA). VEGF165 (PeproTech, Inc., Rocky Hill, NJ), at 50 ng/mL, was applied to both the apical and basolateral sides of the membrane for 30 minutes before the addition of 8.3 μM of PCM107 to the apical chamber. After the addition of PCM107, aliquots were removed at 30-minute intervals (up to 210 minutes) from the basolateral chamber and placed in 96-well polystyrene plates (black with clear bottoms; Corning Costar). A sample was taken from the apical chamber at the last time point and placed in the 96-well plate. The fluorescence of the aliquots was quantified with FLUOstar Omega microplate reader (BMG LABTECH GmbH, Ortenberg, Germany) and the rate of diffusive flux (Po) in centimeters per second was calculated by the following formula: Po = ([F A/Δt]V A)/(F L A), where F A is basolateral fluorescence, FL is apical fluorescence, Δt is change in time, A is the surface area of the filter (cm2), and V A is the volume of the basolateral chamber (in mL).
BRECs grown in MDCB-131 medium (Sigma-Aldrich, St. Louis, MO) supplemented with 10% fetal calf serum, EGF 10 nm/mL, EndoGro 0.2 mg/mL (VEC Technologies, Inc., Rensselaer, NY), heparin 0.09 mg/mL, 1% antibiotic/antimycotic, and 0.1% tylosin were seeded in a 96-well plate (10,000 cells per well) and incubated at 37°C with 5% CO2 for 40 hours before assessed for cytotoxicity. The bottom row of the plate was not seeded and used as blank. After the medium was removed, 100 μL of each dye solution diluted in MDCB-131 medium and a mixture of all four dyes (1× and 10× of the concentrations used in vivo) were added to the wells. Ethanol (10% and 20%) was used as a positive control. After 4 hours incubation at 37°C with 5% CO2, the dye solutions and ethanol were removed and 100 μL of medium containing 10% of WST-1 assay reagent (Roche Diagnostics GmbH, Mannheim, Germany) was added to each well. After another 4 hours of incubation at 37°C with 5% CO2, the absorbance of the plate was measured at 440 nm with reference at 740 nm (FLUOstar Omega; BMG LABTECH GmbH). Data were obtained from triplicated samples and background absorbance from the same treatment without WST-1 reagent was subtracted.
The rabbits were anesthetized with a subcutaneous injection of a mixture of ketamine hydrochloride (35 mg/kg) (Butler Shein Animal Health, Dublin, OH) and xylazine hydrochloride (5 mg/kg) (Lloyd, Inc., Shenandoah, IA). The pupils were dilated with a topical application of phenylephrine hydrochloride 2.5% (Akorn, Inc., Buffalo Grove, IL) and tropicamide 0.5% (Akorn, Inc.) eye drops.
Imaging.
Reading and Scoring PCA Images.
Statistics.
Proliferative Response.
Incomplete Resolution.
The current study uses PCA as a new semiquantitative method to assess BRB dysfunction in rabbits. Intravitreal injection of VEGF produced a differential effect on size-selective permeability of BRB during the 14-day observation period. Higher VEGF doses were associated with more prolonged periods of leakage and higher peak PCA scores. Blocking the effect of VEGF with bevacizumab had the reverse effect (i.e., shortening the period of leakage and lowered PCA scores).
PCA assesses BRB permeability to materials of molecular weight between 376 Da and 70 KDa. The same dynamic range can be covered by using FA and ICG simultaneously. However, in this study the combined PCA2 (10 KDa leaking) and PCA3 (40 KDa leaking) scores constituted 75% of all angiographies with some degree of leakage (PCA scores ≥1), whereas only 15% and 10% had PCA1 (376 Da) and PCA4 (>70 KDa) scores, respectively. This indicates that changes in the BRB following VEGF intravitreous injection in rabbits causes permeability to molecules with molecular weights in the range of 10 KDa or greater and less than 70 KDa and delineates the importance of two intermediate molecular weights in PCA.
In pilot studies, PCM03 (4 KDa) was used as a contrast agent for channel 2 but it was found to leak in all instances in which FA leaked (15 of 15 instances, data not shown). This led us to modify the molecular weight range by use of PCM102 (10 KDa). We also tested PCM103 (20 KDa) in channel 3, but its leakage was nearly identical to PCM102 (11 of 12 instances, data not shown). Accordingly, we increased the size of the channel 3 fluorophore to 40 KDa (PCM107). The dye load for both PCM102 and PCM107 was adjusted to prevent quenching.
In addition to indicating the temporal relation of the start and disappearance of leakage, as reported by others,
15–18 PCA allowed for more detailed analysis of BRB dysfunction by differentiating the effects of the different doses over time, which would not have been possible using FA and/or ICG alone. The PCA score pattern from groups C and E mirrored the changes in OCT measurements seen in rabbits given similar doses of VEGF or VEGF and bevacizumab, respectively.
15,16
In addition to scoring of BRB dysfunction, PCA allowed for the visualization of vascular changes even in the presence of leakage in all but one channel. This permitted the development and use of the VR scoring system. Because PCA uses two long-wavelength channels (CH 3 and CH 4) that penetrate the RPE layer, it is possible to use images from these channels to study the choroid in nonalbino animals. Future studies could explore the effect of different VEGFs on retinal vasculature using PCA.
The decision to use the rabbit eye for this experiment was based on two main reasons: the size of the eye is large enough to allow the use of a clinical fundus camera without changing the optics, and the relatively inexpensive cost of the experiments compared with using nonhuman primates. In addition, there were sufficient data on VEGF-induced leakage in rabbits to use for guidance and comparison. However, because the rabbit retina has significant morphologic differences compared with the human retina (merangiotic vascular distribution with no macula), it is important to validate the use of PCA in nonhuman primates (holoangiotic vascular distribution and a macula with a central avascular fovea). Animal models using VEGF-induced leakage are intended to mimic a state similar to diabetic retinopathy, one of the major retinal vascular diseases. It would be also of interest to validate the use of PCA in the assessment of pathologic processes modeling other retinal conditions, such as neovascular AMD and uveitis.
One of the shortcomings of this study is the lack of histological evidence for the correlation between disease severity and PCA scores. However, in agreement with our results, Lightman et al.
13 have shown a correlation between the molecular weight of fluorescein-labeled dextran leaking from pathological vessels and electron microscopic evidence of retinal pathology. Another shortcoming of this study is the lack of information about the binding of PCM102 and PCM107 to plasma proteins or other plasma molecules. Nevertheless, because PCM102 and PCM107 leaked in instances where ICG did not leak, we may assume that both components are, at least partially, unbound to plasma proteins or other large molecules. This observation is confirmed by the renal excretion of the dyes (urine discoloration, data not included), which would have not been the case if PCM102 and PCM107 were completely bound to plasma proteins or other large plasma components.
Overall, our findings augment the reported correlation between the permeability of BRB to increasing molecular weights and disease progression and regression.
12,13 These data also suggest the potential utility of PCA as a tool to assess and stratify the severity of BRB dysfunction in animal models and, supplemented by previous FITC-dextran reports,
12–14 provide a rationale for furthering the development of PCA for the assessment of BRB dysfunction in humans.
Supported in part by Grant 17-2011-518 from JDRF.
Disclosure: S.R. Tari, PCAsso Diagnostics LLC (I, E), P; M. Youssif, PCAsso Diagnostics LLC (E); C.M. Samson, PCAsso Diagnostics LLC (I, C); R.L. Harris, None; C.-M. Lin, None; U.B. Kompella, PCAsso Diagnostics LLC (F), P; D.A. Antonetti, None; G.R. Barile, PCAsso Diagnostics LLC (I, C), P