In this study, Fu appeared to decline significantly in rhesus monkeys older than 25 years compared with younger age groups, even as close in age as 19 to 23 years. Based on existing human data,
8 Fu also decreases in healthy humans older than 60 years (equivalent to our 25- to 29-year old monkeys) compared with 20- to 30-year-olds. Whether there is a gradual or a dramatic decline in Fu in humans has not been determined. Townsend and Brubaker
22 calculated Fu to be 34% ± 12% of AHF in control eyes of 24-year-old humans, similar to our finding in our 3- to 23-year-old monkeys (37% ± 4%). Purported monkey versus human differences in Fu in earlier comparisons are probably due largely to age and/or disease state differences, rather than to species differences. A study by Bill and Philips
10 of Fu in humans was undertaken in 48- to 73-year-old eyes, most of which harbored malignant melanomas. They suggested that the increase in polysaccharide material that often occurs in choroidal melanomas probably impedes flow through the TM and CM. The large scatter and the weak correlation in the plots of Fu or flow to blood or Fu versus age in our monkeys (
r 2 ≤ 0.1;
Figs. 3 4 , respectively) indicates that experimental noise or other factors are also at play.
Previous studies showed an age-related decrease in total outflow facility in both monkeys
14 and humans.
2 6 9 In humans, reduced formation of giant vacuoles in the inner wall endothelium of Schlemm’s canal has been proposed to account for the age-related increase in outflow resistance (Roy S, Boldea R, Leuba S, Mermoud A, ARVO Abstract 733, 2001) but this is only one of many possibilities. The amount and induction of mRNA for various matrix metalloproteinases decreased with age of porcine trabecular cell cultures exposed to 15 and 50 mm Hg of pressure for 72 hours (Ehrich D, Tripathi BJ, Tripathi RC, Duncker GIW, Gotsis S, ARVO Abstract 748, 2001). In human TM cells, there may also be a passage-number–related reduction in matrix metalloproteinase activity (Williams GC, Borrás T, Pizzo SV, ARVO Abstract 764, 2001). Findings in both of the latter studies suggest a reduced capacity to break down extracellular material, which could contribute to a reduction of outflow either through the TM or through the Fu pathway. Also, a reduction in CM movement
23 reflected by the onset of presbyopia in humans and monkeys which is complete by approximately 55 years in humans and 25 years in rhesus monkeys,
24 could contribute to an environment in which extracellular material could accumulate in the CM and TM outflow pathways.
25
In our study and inferred from Toris et al.,
8 the flow of fluid through the trabecular outflow pathway actually appears to increase with age when the starting IOP is normal. Trabecular outflow facility was not measured as part of the present study. An increase in trabecular flow would not by itself rule out a decrease in trabecular outflow facility.
However, if trabecular outflow facility (C
trab) and Fu decrease while AHF remains stable, IOP must increase or episcleral venous pressure (Pe) must decline, based on the Goldmann equation: AHF = C
trab (IOP − Pe) + Fu. Because IOP appears to increase with age in the monkeys we studied
(Fig. 1) , whereas AHF remained unchanged and Fu decreased, a decrease in trabecular outflow facility with age is possible. Our morphologic and physiological data suggest that the age-related increases in IOP in this sample of monkeys may reflect changes in the uveoscleral as well as the trabecular outflow pathway (discussed later). However the physiologic changes in aqueous humor drainage in our studies appear not to occur uniformly throughout life but change rather precipitously at 25 years of age. Morphologic changes seem to occur more uniformly with age. It may be that a threshold in morphologic changes must occur before there are any changes in physiologic response.
The increased appearance of isotope in the blood in older animals can be explained in two ways: Either almost all the fluid goes through the TM, or Fu channels empty into the blood more promptly. In the first case, the normal elevation in IOP with age may produce a widening of the paracellular channels between the inner-wall endothelium
26 and a loosening of the cell–cell attachments that form them, allowing more fluid to flow through this route in a nondiseased eye. The second possibility suggests that Fu channels become more “leaky” or are otherwise altered with age. However the change in Fu was not continuous throughout life, but rather occurred precipitously in very old age. If the vasculature in general becomes more leaky with age, then the blood-equivalent albumin space in monkeys aged more than 25 years would be expected to be greater than in those aged less than 19 years, which was not the case. In adult humans, leakiness remained largely unchanged from 18 to 77 years.
27 Scleral hydraulic conductivity does not appear to change with age in humans (Noury AM, Jackson TL, Hodgetts A, Marshall J, ARVO Abstract 3580, 2001). If we assume the same blood-equivalent albumin space in all animals, then the difference in Fu in the two age groups is even more striking (Gabelt BT, Kaufman PL, ARVO Abstract 2749, 2000).
There has been a debate about whether Fu actually passes through the sclera versus flowing into the choroidal blood.
28 However, these arguments in no way negate the use of protein tracers as a marker. Any protein appearing in the blood shortly after its introduction into the anterior chamber can be assumed to have been carried to the blood by transtrabecular flow. Therefore the calculation of Fu as the difference of AHF and flow to blood would not depend on the exact route of Fu.
Prior studies of the aging CM have revealed some cellular changes that seem unlikely to have consequences for bulk fluid flow through the tissue, which is more likely to depend on events in the intermuscular spaces and perhaps especially at the anterior entrance to those spaces at the trabeculum ciliare. The trabeculum ciliare is a network of elastic and collagen fibers between the iris root, the uveal portion of the TM, and the CM tips. It is covered by cells anteriorly and connected to the basement membrane of the CM cells and the connective tissue between the CM bundles at their tips posteriorly. Aqueous humor must pass through the spaces of the trabeculum ciliare to gain entrance to the spaces between the CM tips, which constitute the entrance to the Fu pathway.
In the present study, there was a significant increase in thickness of the elastic fibers of the trabeculum ciliare with age in rhesus monkeys. Cross sections through the elastic fibers and their sheaths form the so called sheath-derived plaques.
29 Sheath-derived plaques at the muscle tips increase with age in human eyes and especially so in glaucomatous eyes.
29 The plaques at the muscle tips in old rhesus monkeys presumably are not large enough to reduce Fu themselves but may indicate a general increase in extracellular material in the CM tips and a consequent reduction in the size of the “gateway” openings for entrance of aqueous humor into the Fu pathways.
The number of pigmented cells in the inner and posterior parts of the CM in rhesus monkeys increases with age,
15 but the most anterior portions are spared until after age 20 years, at which point the spaces between the muscle fiber bundles contain a greatly increased number of pigmented cells compared with younger animals. This is especially prominent after age 25 years when pigmented cells are present even between the tips of the anterior longitudinal portion of the muscle. The correlation with the dramatic decrease of Fu over age 25 is noteworthy but could be either a contributing factor to or the result of decreased Fu.
With increasing age in rhesus monkeys, we found an increase in sheath-derived plaques and fibrillar material in the juxtacanalicular region and a decrease in overall cellularity of the TM. All these findings also occur in human eyes with increasing age. After filtration surgery in young normal monkeys increased plaque formation also occurred in the TM, presumably consequent to underperfusion.
30 If underperfusion causes plaque formation in our old monkeys, this could explain why changes in the TM show more interindividual variability (between animals of the same age) than do the CM entrance changes. Because AHF does not decline noticeably with age, the flow may wash out and degrade sheath material in the TM. This would be less true in the muscle tips with severely reduced Fu.
In conclusion, our results in monkeys and those of Toris et al.
8 in humans, using independent techniques with different assumptions and potential flaws, both indicate that Fu decreases at older ages in eyes with normal IOP and normal findings in biomicroscopy. This decrease in Fu with age could be especially important in elderly patients with glaucoma, in whom outflow facility through the TM is also compromised.
31
The authors thank the Wisconsin Regional Primate Research Center for making available to us rhesus monkeys of various age groups for the in vivo studies and for providing eyes from animals euthanatized for other protocols, and Jennifer Seeman, DVM, for providing expertise in performing femoral artery cannulations for blood collection.