After intravenous administration, ICG is not toxic in animals, and the median lethal dose (LD
50) ranges from 50 to 80 mg/kg in mice.
31 32 33 34 There are no equivalent data in humans. The maximum recommended dose for intravenous application in humans is 5 mg/kg. However, a low intravascular toxicity of ICG does not necessarily mean that ICG is nontoxic to intraocular structures. In the vascular system, ICG is rapidly bound to proteins and thereby excreted from the tissue.
39 In the eye, there may be a different situation regarding the binding properties of ICG, the distribution of the dye, and the effect of ICG on intraocular tissue. In vitro, a 5-mg/mL (0.5%) ICG solution is toxic to cultured lens epithelial cells.
40 Brief exposure of cultured human retinal pigment epithelial cells to 0.1% ICG solution results in decreased mitochondrial enzyme activity but does not appear to influence cellular morphology.
20 There is a recent report
17 on morphologic and functional damage of ICG to the rat retina in vivo after vitrectomy and intravitreous ICG administration. Ten days after application, 0.25 mg/mL of ICG was found to cause significant morphologic damage to all layers of the retina.
During surgery, injecting 0.2 mL 0.05% ICG into the fluid-filled globe with an assumed volume of the vitreous cavity of 4 mL, usually provides an equivalent dose of ICG of 0.25 mg/mL (0.0025%), which is half of the maximum recommended intravenous dose in humans and one tenth of the damaging dose in rat eyes.
17 However, the exposure times in the animal model and during surgery are essentially different, and conclusions regarding toxicity cannot be drawn from simple mathematics.
Moreover, the intravitreous concentration of ICG may not reflect the real distribution of the dye within the eye, especially not at the vitreoretinal interface, where ICG may accumulate because of a possible rapid binding of the dye to proteins. In plasma, 80% of ICG is bound to globulins, probably α-1 lipoproteins.
39 At the vitreoretinal interface, there are no data concerning the binding sites of ICG to the ILM. It has been reported, however, that apolipoproteins are secreted by Müller cells, effectively assembled into lipoprotein particles, and secreted into the vitreous.
41 Therefore, it can be assumed that lipoproteins and other proteins that are present at the ILM may account for binding of ICG to the ILM resulting in an accumulation of the dye at the vitreomacular interface. Persistent ICG fluorescence at the vitreoretinal interface has been reported 6 weeks after ICG administration in macular hole surgery.
42 The intense staining of the ILM and the clear contrast between the vitreous, the retina, and the ILM after intravitreous application of ICG further suggest an accumulation of ICG at the vitreoretinal interface, which may enhance the concentration of ICG at the inner retina beyond intravitreous values and theoretical expectations.
11 15
In the present experimental setting, application of ICG without illumination resulted in detachment of the ILM from the retina. Ultrastructural analysis disclosed plasma membranes of Müller cells and cellular debris adherent to the ILM, exactly as it has been observed after ICG guided removal of the ILM during surgery for macular holes, macular pucker, vitreomacular traction syndrome, and diffuse diabetic macular edema (Haritoglou C, manuscript submitted; and Haritoglou C, Gandorfer A, Gass CA, Kampik A, ARVO Abstract, 3516, 2002).
19 It should be noted that no attempt at peeling was made in the present study. ICG alone was sufficient to separate the ILM from the retina, reflecting the ease of membrane removal after staining with ICG in macular surgery. The cleavage plane, however, was not at the inner undulating aspect of the ILM—as in peeling of the ILM without the use of ICG—but within the innermost retinal layer (Haritoglou C, Gandorfer A, Gass CA, Kampik A, ARVO Abstract, 3516, 2002).
5 19
From the present experimental setting we cannot conclude what finally may have caused Müller cell damage. Osmolarity and pH of the ICG solution applied were 279 mOsM and 7.5, respectively (data not shown). It could be hypothesized, however, that accumulation of the dye at the ILM may have raised the osmolarity at the vitreomacular interface beyond critical limits. Marmor
43 investigated the impact of hyperosmotic solutions on the retina. Within seconds to a minute, elevation and glistening of the vitreomacular interface occurred, finally resulting in retinal detachment.
43 The weakest solutions that produced ophthalmoscopically visible changes to the retina were near 500 mOsM. Nonspecific shrinkage and disruption of normal cellular orientation were characteristics of osmotic cellular damage.
44 Marmor et al.
44 and Okinami et al.
45 observed that severe osmotic stress may cause rupture of cells but does not split cells apart at their intercellular junctions. These findings and the observation of Marmor et al.
44 of detachment of the vitreomacular interface after application of a hyperosmotic solution are consistent with the ultrastructural findings in the present study. Cellular swelling and formation of cysts near the cellular boundary, disruption of cells and fragmentation of the cell membrane with preserved intercellular junctions were characteristic features of osmotic damage in the series of Marmor et al.
44 and were all found in the present study after application of ICG to the macula. Therefore, we assume an osmotic effect of ICG at the inner retina after accumulation of the dye at the vitreomacular interface, despite regular osmolarity of the ICG solution applied. This mechanism of action may account for recent reports on retinal toxicity of ICG, the ease of membrane removal during surgery, and the alteration of the cleavage plane reported previously.
17 19
However, most severe damage to the inner retina occurred after ICG staining of the ILM and illumination with wavelengths beyond 620 nm. Loss of the ILM, disruption of the nerve fiber layer, and gross cellular disorganization with fragmentation of the cytoplasm were found in all four ICG-stained eyes that were exposed to the near-infrared and infrared spectrum. Neither ICG alone, nor ICG followed by illumination of the posterior pole with wavelengths between 380 and 620 nm, nor illumination of the posterior pole without the use of ICG resulted in these ultrastructural findings, supporting evidence for a photodynamic effect of ICG at the vitreoretinal interface.
ICG is a tricarbocyanine type of dye with infrared absorption properties and a peak absorption at approximately 800 nm in blood plasma. The light-absorption properties of ICG depend not only on the concentration but also on the solute. In water, ICG tends to aggregate at high concentrations, causing a shift of the absorption maximum from 800 to 700 nm.
35 Moreover, the measurement of the absorption properties of ICG as administered in this experimental setting and during surgery disclose a shift of the absorption band starting at 600 nm and steeply increasing beyond. Regarding the irradiance of the light pipe of one randomly chosen vitrectomy instrument (Megatron; Geuder), there is still 28% of the total irradiance beyond 600 nm. These results and the presence of severe inner retinal damage in all ICG-stained eyes that have been exposed to the near infrared and infrared spectrum support experimental evidence for a photodynamic effect of ICG at the vitreoretinal interface.
Regarding the mechanisms of action of photodynamic cytotoxicity, the molecule’s absorbed energy can be converted to heat and transferred to other molecules (photooxidation I), damaging cells by raising their intracellular temperature, as shown by the use of ICG in photocoagulation or tissue welding.
35 46 47 48 49 Alternatively, the photosensitizer’s energy can be transferred to molecular oxygen (photooxidation II), forming a triplet stage that interacts with oxygen and other molecules to generate reactive intermediates, such as singlet oxygen.
37 Ultrastructural analysis of cultured human skin cells after ICG-mediated phototherapy revealed cytoplasmic vesiculation; dilatation of the rough endoplasmic reticulum, the Golgi complex, and the perinuclear cisternae; and chromatin condensation in the nucleus.
36 A previous report demonstrated the toxic effect of ICG on rat liver mitochondria in vitro.
50
It is not surprising that we did not observe these ultrastructural features of intracellular damage. In living cells, uptake of ICG is a carrier-mediated and saturable transport process leading to intracytoplasmic damage.
36 It is not known whether this active transport mechanism is compromised in postmortem cells and which role other mechanisms of action play, such as diffusion with subsequent accumulation of the dye at diffusion barriers.
From the present experimental setting, we cannot conclude which type of photooxidation may have caused inner retinal damage. Given the assumption that the ILM may act as a diffusion barrier for a water-soluble molecule with a molecular weight of 775 kDa such as ICG, the ultrastructural findings in the present study are more likely to be caused by a thermal type I reaction of photoactivation rather than by a type II reaction of intracellular generation of singlet oxygen. Further evidence of this hypothesis, however, must be obtained from an animal model.
Although an experimental setting does not reflect the situation during surgery, the present data are consistent with previous work and support further evidence that ICG staining of the ILM may cause retinal damage under certain still poorly understood circumstances. Amounts of ICG currently administered in macular surgery cause a shift in the absorption behavior of the dye toward 600 nm, which may result in a photodynamic effect of ICG at the inner retina after exposure to wavelengths beyond 600 nm. Accumulation of ICG at the ILM may exceed the concentration measured in the vitreous and may enhance the osmolarity of ICG at the retina beyond critical limits. Thus, further work is needed to define a safe surgical setting when the dye should be administered later in macular surgery.
The authors thank Monika Volkholz and Alex Feller for excellent technical assistance.