In this study, both
Otx2 and
Crx inductions effectively led ciliary- and iris-derived cells to differentiate into a photoreceptor-specific phenotype. These photoreceptor-like cells induced by
Otx2 and
Crx misexpressions displayed photoreceptor-specific morphology in vitro. A recently conducted extensive experiment, using an
Otx2 conditional knockout mouse line in which the
Otx2 genes were inactivated under control of the
Crx promoter, proved that
Otx2 is a key regulatory gene for photoreceptor development.
12 In our study,
Otx2 induction effectively led ciliary- and iris-derived cells to differentiate into a photoreceptor-specific phenotype. However, the mechanism of the photoreceptor generation remains obscure, in that
Otx2 expression is not restricted to the photoreceptor cells, but covers most of the forebrain and midbrain, including the eye domain in the developmental stage.
24 Furthermore,
Otx2 expression in the eye has been demonstrated in several cell types, including bipolar cells, ganglion cells, photoreceptor cells, and retinal pigment epithelial cells.
12 25 26 In addition,
Otx2 has been shown to be a direct upstream regulator of
Crx, so that
Crx is also thought to be misexpressed in
Otx2-induced cells.
12 Crx appears to be capable of inducing photoreceptor-specific phenotypes in ciliary- and iris-derived cells, although further studies are needed to examine the differences between
Crx- and
Otx2-induced cells in terms of other photoreceptor-specific characteristics, including photoresponsiveness, which may provide the key to producing genuine functional photoreceptors.
The pigmented cells of the adult mouse ciliary marginal zone contain a population of retinal stem cells.
13 14 We cultured pigmented cells of the ciliary margin and successfully obtained neurospheres; however, without gene induction the level of expression of rod opsin by the differentiated cells in our experiment was very small compared with the a previously report.
13 This low rod photoreceptor-generating capability is possibly due to different culture conditions, including dissociation and culture media. Another possible cause is the difference in species—that is, mouse and rat.
13 Although the culture conditions for ciliary-derived cells need improvement,
Crx or
Otx2 induction helped increase the differentiation efficiency of photoreceptor cells dramatically.
It has been reported that cultured human ciliary epithelial cells have the potential to express components of phototransduction,
27 whereas iris tissue also reportedly to has the potential to respond to light in vitro and in vivo by following a non-neural pathway.
28 29 30 31 32 The iris-derived cells in our study, however, did not differentiate into cells expressing rod opsin, recoverin, and G∂t1 without appropriate gene induction, which means that rat iris tissue does not normally express components of phototransduction. The possible explanation for this is that iris-derived cells normally have the potential to express these components, including rhodopsin, but that their expression levels are too low to be detectable by immunocytochemistry.
We have reported that
Crx does not induce rhodopsin immunoreactivity in hippocampus-derived neural stem cells.
16 In the current study, some cell populations responded to
Crx or
Otx2 induction in neurospheres derived from the embryonic mesencephalon, although only very few did so. This lack of uniformity may be explained in terms of the different characteristics between the long-cultured neural stem cells and the freshly obtained neural progenitor cells. Further studies are needed to find an explanation for the inhibitory effects of other gene products, which may result in gaining information as to how to produce photoreceptor cells from other tissues.
In conclusion, forced expression of the Otx2 gene, in the same manner as the Crx gene, effectively induced the cells derived from the adult iris and ciliary margin to become photoreceptor-like cells, whereas most of the mesencephalon-derived neural stem cells did not respond to Otx2. Furthermore, the Crx- and Otx2-transfected rat iris-derived cells expressed at least two additional key components of the phototransduction cascade. Thus, the Otx2 gene is one of the key regulators of both normal photoreceptor development and, by means of gene delivery, photoreceptor production.
The authors thank Constance L. Cepko (Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA) and Takahisa Furukawa (Osaka Bioscience Institute, Osaka, Japan) for their generous gift of Crx cDNA.