The findings of this study indicate for the first time that aging in mice is associated with an increased susceptibility to the action of α-toxin, either when the toxin is produced by S. aureus in the eye or applied in a pure form topically to the eye. The extent of pathogenesis of keratitis in aged mice infected with either toxin-deficient mutant strain of S. aureus was greatly reduced compared with infection with the parent strain that produces the full spectrum of toxins. α-Toxin, in concentrations of only 5 ng, applied topically to the scarified eyes of aged mice caused more severe pathologic changes than those observed in toxin-treated eyes of young mice. Aged mice treated with α-toxin demonstrated PMN infiltration throughout the entire thickness of the cornea and extensive PMN accumulation below Descemet’s membrane, changes that did not occur in eyes of young mice treated similarly with α-toxin.
In this study, eyes of young mice infected with either mutant strain of
S. aureus demonstrated much less severe disease than eyes infected with the parent strain. These results were even more dramatic in eyes of aged mice, suggesting that toxin susceptibility may increase with age. In addition, the eyes of aged mice were far more susceptible to the damaging effects of topically administered α-toxin than were those of young mice, as evidenced by SLE and histopathologic analysis. These findings are consistent with the studies of
Staphylococcus toxins in mice in nonocular sites that suggest that aged mice may be more susceptible than young mice, because of a greater susceptibility to staphylococcal toxins.
32
The mutant
S. aureus strains analyzed in this study were engineered to differ from the parent strain in only a single genetic locus.
23 24 25 Based on this fact, the finding of a reduced population of bacteria in corneas infected with toxin-deficient mutants, compared with the parent strain, suggests that toxins facilitate
Staphylococcus infection. The fact that
S. aureus strain DU1090 is only deficient in α-toxin suggests that α-toxin promotes the infection of the cornea as well as causes extensive pathologic changes. α-Toxin could provide enhanced bacterial translocation through the epithelium, an increase in nutrients at the site of infection due to degradation of cornea components, or protection of bacteria in the inflamed cornea. The higher SLE scores for α-toxin-deficient bacterial infections compared with infections with the Agr-deficient strain suggest that a toxin other than α-toxin also contributes to corneal damage in the mouse. Dajcs et al.
33 found that γ-toxin is a corneal virulence factor in the rabbit model of keratitis, suggesting that production of γ-toxin by the α-toxin-deficient mutant could explain its greater virulence relative to the Agr-deficient mutant. This role of γ-toxin should be further studied in this model.
Both histopathologic analyses and MPO assays demonstrated that the PMN infiltrate into eyes infected with the parent strain was greater than that of infections with either mutant strain. The reduced infiltrate observed in infection with the α-toxin-deficient strain demonstrate that this toxin is responsible for a chemotactic response in the cornea. This point was substantiated by the histopathologic analysis of eyes treated with purified α-toxin.
Overall, there are very few studies that have analyzed the prevalence and course of microbial keratitis in the elderly. However, microbial keratitis appears to be significantly more prevalent in the elderly population than in the general population, perhaps due to decreased host resistance associated with aging.
34 Aged patients are at high risk for keratitis caused by
S. aureus or other ocular pathogens, including
P. aeruginosa.
15 34 35 36 In the study conducted by Ormerod,
34 the symptoms of keratitis were more severe in aged than in young patients. The rates of corneal ulcer formation appeared to be higher in the elderly population than in younger patients.
34 Hypopyon was present in 48% of the aged patients, and spontaneous hyphema developed at a much higher rate in aged than in younger patients.
34 Also, higher rates of descemetocele and corneal perforation were noted in patients >65 years of age.
34 Several studies have indicated that anatomic or physiological changes may mediate this apparent increased predisposition to infection in the elderly including a decline in tear production, impairment of healing processes, such as epithelial cell regeneration, and a decline in a wide range of immunologic responses.
34 37 38 However, the role of bacterial virulence factors in keratitis in elderly patients has not been analyzed. The results of the present study indicate that aged mouse eyes are more susceptible to
Staphylococcus α-toxin, suggesting that a similar increased susceptibility to toxin could explain the observed increased severity of keratitis in the aged human eye. Not only is the toxin responsible for more severe pathologic changes, but it appears to aid in the ability of the bacteria to invade or survive in the cornea.
The findings of this study illustrate for the first time that the eyes of aged mice are more susceptible to staphylococcal α-toxin than young mice. These results suggest that the elderly population may be at a greater risk for more severe keratitis caused by Staphylococcus than are younger individuals and that inhibition of the action of α-toxin in the cornea is essential to limiting the damage associated with S. aureus keratitis, particularly in the aged. The availability of the murine model for the identification of inhibitors of α-toxin could be very beneficial and could provide further insight into the use of immunotherapy targeted to α-toxin for Staphylococcus keratitis.
The authors thank Brett Thibodeaux for technical assistance with the research.