Bacteria were found to be transcytosed across M cells above conjunctival lymphoid follicles and to move deeper into the follicle with time. These findings demonstrate that conjunctival M cells, like those in other mucosal locations, are a site of entry for large microbes and may be an entry point for bacterial and viral pathogens. Nontypeable (nonencapsulated)
H. influenzae are commensal bacteria of the human upper respiratory tract, but under appropriate conditions are responsible for many mucosal diseases including conjunctivitis, otitis media, sinusitis, and bronchitis.
20 H. influenzae has not been reported to cause experimental conjunctivitis in the guinea pig although the species has been used for studying NTHi-mediated otitis media. The guinea pig was chosen as a model system to study how microbes may cross the mucosal barrier, because conjunctival M cells in this species are known to express α(2-3) sialic acid selectively on the apical surface and the well-characterized ability of some NTHi strains to bind this carbohydrate made it a convenient probe. The intent of the present study was not to investigate bacterial conjunctivitis in the guinea pig, but to demonstrate that conjunctival M cells are a potential port of entry for microbes. Numerous studies have found potentially pathogenic bacteria such as NTHi,
Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and
Staphylococcus aureus in the conjunctiva of normal individuals with no overt signs of infection.
21 22 23 In addition, nonpathogenic commensal bacteria such as
Propionibacterium spp and
Staphylococcus epidermidis are often found in the conjunctiva.
6 21 23 Bacterial colonization is prevented by innate immune factors in the tear film, such as lysozyme, lactoferrin, and lactoperoxidase, as well as adaptive immune responses generating bacteria-specific IgA. IgA prevents colonization by binding to bacterial adhesins and preventing bacteria adhesion to the mucosal surfaces. IgA-mediated agglutination of bacteria may also play a role in limiting colonization. IgA antibodies against NTHi,
S. epidermidis,
P. aeruginosa,
Escherichia coli, and herpes simplex virus have all been found in the tears of asymptomatic human volunteers.
4 5 6 The present studies suggest a mechanism for the initiation of the local mucosal immune response against commensal or transient ocular bacterial species.
Adherence and subsequent colonization are essential first steps in NTHi pathogenesis, and these bacteria have evolved multiple adhesins.
24 One of the better characterized adhesins, HMW1, a high-molecular-weight protein expressed on the surface of 51% to 80% of clinical isolates,
24 25 mediates adhesion to epithelial cells via α(2-3) linked sialic acid.
11 Maackia amurensis agglutinin (MAA), which generally refers to an unfractionated mixture of MAL-I and MAL-II, has been shown to reduce OM12 binding to Chang epithelial cells by 74%.
11 In the present study, MAL-I reduced OM12 uptake by 61%. These observations indicate that OM12 binding to guinea pig conjunctival M cells is partially mediated by HMW1. It is likely, however, that OM12 expresses other adhesins that assist in its binding to M cells. In addition, it is likely that M cells have other receptors that have broad specificity for both Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria. Two recent papers highlight a possible role for Toll-like receptors (TLRs) expressed on M cells in the intestinal tract.
26 27 TLRs are a family of pattern recognition receptors which recognize conserved motifs of bacterial and viral pathogens. Further studies are needed to determine whether TLRs and other pattern recognition receptors may play a role in M cell sampling in the conjunctiva.
The guinea pig conjunctiva is not the only site with M-cell α(2-3) linked sialic acid glycoconjugates. The attachment and translocation of reovirus by M cells in the rabbit Peyer’s patch has been shown to be mediated by α(2-3) linked sialic acid-containing glycoconjugates. The sialic acid-binding lectins MAL-I and -II inhibit binding by reovirus to these cells.
28 Because MAL-II bound to the surface of all rabbit intestinal cells, both inside and outside the FAE, these investigators concluded that the sialic acid epitope may be on a membrane component common to all intestinal epithelial cells but that larger ligands such as reovirus can only interact with it on M cells, because they have a reduced glycocalyx. Although the glycocalyx on guinea pig conjunctival epithelial cells is less extensive than in the intestinal tract, it still forms a dense coat extending 300 nm out from the microvilli and microplicae of the surface.
29 Less is known about the glycocalyx above the follicle-associated epithelium of the conjunctiva, but M-cell microvilli are sparse and pleiomorphic, which would be likely to lead to a reduced, less uniform glycocalyx.
2 It is important to note that in the guinea pig conjunctiva, the M cell is the only epithelial cell type that expresses α(2-3)-linked sialic acid on the apical surface, and therefore it may be associated with an M cell-specific glycoprotein or glycolipid.
2
NTHi may not be the only Gram-negative bacteria that cross the conjunctiva via M cells. The guinea pig conjunctiva has been used for many years to test for bacterial invasiveness, by using the so-called “Sereny test.” The Sereny test is a routinely used assay for
Shigella virulence in which
Shigella flexneri are inoculated into the conjunctival sacs of guinea pigs and the degree of keratoconjunctivitis is evaluated.
30 31 Because
S. flexneri are unable to penetrate the apical membranes of polarized cells,
32 it is reasonable to assume they are crossing conjunctival M cells and triggering inflammation in a manner identical with their entry across the intestinal mucosa via Peyer’s patch M cells.
33 Of note, two other bacterial species that test positive in the Sereny test,
Salmonella typhimurium 34 and
Yersinia enterocolitica,
35 are also known to cross the intestinal mucosal barrier via M cells.
36
The absence of mucosal lymphoid follicles and their associated M cells in the conjunctiva of mice and rats has delayed the recognition of this important cell type in ocular mucosa. Mice and rats do have extensive nasal-associated lymphoid tissue (NALT) and drainage from the nasolacrimal duct that may take the place of CALT. The absence of CALT in mice and rats suggests that they may be poor models for the study of human ocular allergy or microbial uptake, since human CALT is more similar to that of the rabbit and guinea pig. In humans, CALT is initially absent in full-term infants, but follicles are routinely observed by 1 year of age. An average of 33 follicles/eye is found in children 6 to 10 years of age.
37 Consistent with other follicular tissue, CALT involutes with age but more than half the eyes in elderly patients have an average of 10 follicles.
38 M cells have yet to be characterized as part of the normal human CALT, but it would be surprising if they were not, based on their presence in the guinea pig and rabbit.
Future studies are needed to determine whether clinically important human ocular pathogens such as herpes simplex virus use conjunctival M cells as a port of entry. In addition, it may be possible to use M-cell targeted immunogens as vehicles to elicit local mucosal immune responses against microbial pathogens or ocular allergens.