In conclusion, we have demonstrated that the normal cornea in fact possesses a heterogeneous population of resident bone-marrow–derived cells, including DCs. These cells have the unique feature of being universally immature or of a precursor phenotype and hence have the “disguising” feature of being ubiquitously MHC class II–negative, and many of these cells, including the DCs, have the functional plasticity of migrating out of the cornea, overexpressing requisite costimulatory molecules, presenting antigen, and stimulating T cells under inflammatory conditions. Moreover, we have shown how the processes that mediate the ingress of these APC populations into the cornea during inflammation are distinct from those that mediate the egress of these cells into lymphatics, demonstrating how the modulation of each of these steps can affect induction of immunity to corneal antigens.
Many critical issues remain unresolved. For example, it is thought that resident APCs in the periphery are recruited from the intravascular compartment. Given that the bone marrow elements we have identified in the cornea are universally MHC class II–negative, whereas only a small population of similar cells in the blood are in such a premature state, there are two relevant questions: Where do the corneal cells come from, and what microenvironmental factors suppress the maturity state of these leukocytes as they gain entry into the normal cornea? Finally, whereas we have focused on the role of these resident bone marrow elements in inducing immune responsiveness, it is critical to determine what role, if any, these cells may have in the induction of tolerance.
Although we expect that ongoing investigations will eventually provide insights into the answers to these questions, it is also important to emphasize the general implications of these findings in terms of our understanding of corneal physiology and immunopathology. Whether it has been generation of immunity to transplants or innate immune responses to infection or injury, the cornea has historically been seen as a simple collagenous tissue at the mercy of the host immune system. The novel findings described herein may lead to a paradigm shift in our understanding of corneal immunity as we move away from the concept of the cornea as a passive bystander, to a model that incorporates its role as an active participant in orchestrating the immune system in response to foreign or autoantigens.
I am greatly indebted to the many trainees who have worked in my laboratory. It is through their commitment to our shared scientific and educational goals and their tenacity and ingeniousness that we are able to make new discoveries. Specifically, I thank the following individuals (listed alphabetically) for their contribution to the work I have presented in the Cogan Lecture: In the area of cytokines and chemokines, Clay Beauregard, Iva Dekaris, Sudhir Vora, Jun Yamada, Satoru Yamagami, and Suning Zhu; in the area of APC phenotyping and function, Lu Chen, Pedram Hamrah, Syed Huq, Ying Liu, and Qiang Zhang; in the area of costimulation, Ying Qian and Vikas Tewari; and in the area of ocular surface inflammation, Mini Balaram and Abha Sood-Gulati. I extend special thanks to Jackie Doherty for assisting in the management of our laboratory research team and to Pedram Hamrah for assistance in the preparation of the manuscript. In addition, I acknowledge the contribution of several key colleagues and collaborators in our research (listed alphabetically): Gilles Benichou, Ilene Gipson, Andrius Kazlauskas, Bruce Ksander, Wayne Streilein, David Sullivan, and Andrew Taylor. I also thank the following sources who have been instrumental in allowing us to pursue our research goals: The National Eye Institute, the Eye Bank Association of America, Research to Prevent Blindness, Fight-For-Sight, the U.S. Department of Defense, Massachusetts Lions Eye Research Fund, and the corporations Allergan, Amgen, and Biogen. I have been fortunate to have benefited immensely from the guidance provided me by my teachers and mentors throughout my education and career. It is not possible to list all the individuals who have helped me through the years, but, in particular, I would like to acknowledge my colleague and mentor, J. Wayne Streilein, MD, for his guidance, support, and encouragement through the years.