A previous retinal histopathologic study of an 11.5-year-old
GUCY2D-mutant LCA patient reported the presence of rods and cones in the macula, in the absence of outer segments. The thickness of the inner nuclear layer was normal, but a thinning of the ganglion cell layer was observed.
22 Macular SD-OCT results in our patients with
GUCY2D mutations demonstrated a similar preservation of retinal lamellar structures with a visible PSJ. This finding is consistent with a previously published observation in a 31-year-old Italian patient with
GUCY2D mutations.
23 We did not find significant differences in retinal microstructures among the patients whose ages ranged from 20 to 53 years. Although this group of patients retained good retinal lamellar structures, their visual acuity was markedly impaired. This dichotomy in structureal–functional relationships appears to characterize the LCA retinas with
GUCY2D mutations and may suggest that this form of LCA represents a biochemical dysfunction with comparatively less structural retinal degeneration, which may bode well for future therapeutic strategies.
Cideciyan et al.
24 described a characteristic retention of the outer retinal layer in the central macula in
CEP290-mutant LCA patients by using time-domain optical coherence tomography (TD-OCT). This finding was found to be independent of the severity in impairment of visual acuity. All the patients with
CEP290 mutations in that study had at least one IVS26+1655 A>G sequence variation. Our macular SD-OCT results showed that, of the seven
CEP290-mutant patients, all six with a IVS26+1655 A>G sequence variation retained the ONL in the central macular area, although it was less apparent with increasing age. However, another patient (number 8) with a different sequence variation had a markedly thin foveal center without a well-defined ONL. Inner retinal structures in
CEP290 mutation-bearing patients were distorted. Three patients with
CEP290 mutations (all had an IVS26+1655 A>G sequence variation) were found to have cystlike lesions in the inner retina.
Several previous TD-OCT studies showed that young
RPE65-mutant LCA patients (age ≤25 years) may present with preserved retinal lamellar architecture.
23,25,26 However, the thickness of the ONL may be reduced. This photoreceptor cell loss was not clearly related to age.
26 Although most of our patients with an
RPE65 mutation were older than those in previous studies,
23,25,26 our results showed that, using higher resolution SD-OCT scans, preservation of lamellar structures and the PSJ was not appreciated, even in a 20-year-old
RPE65-mutant patient. The macular lamellar architecture was appreciably distorted and tended to worsen with an increase in the patients' age. This observation may imply that heterogeneity of phenotypic expression is present, even in patients with different variations in the same gene, as also seen in
CEP290-mutant patients. Nonetheless, in fact, our patients with an
RPE65 mutation had a higher median age than did those with other mutations. This may also, in part, contribute to our finding a higher prevalence of lens opacity in this genetic subtype.
Although an automated image segmentation algorithm was reported to be useful for an evaluation of thickness profiles in eyes with well-preserved lamellar architectures,
21 it did not accurately segment the retina into different layers in those with disorganized lamellar structures in any of our LCA patients in this study. We found that manual segmentation was more reliable; however, it was also more time-consuming. Because our patients were very poorly sighted, with various degrees of nystagmus, well-centered images were difficult to obtain that could ensure an accurate measurement of macular thickness. However, the findings from our image acquisitions provide useful comparative data among different genetic subtypes of LCA.
This study demonstrates that SD-OCT macular imaging is a potentially useful method of differentiating certain patients with different genotypes. Preservation of retinal microanatomic structures may not be associated with better visual acuity. Nevertheless, such preservation, for instance, of lamellar architectures in GUCY2D-mutant patients, and of ONL in the central macula in CEP290-mutant cases, may have an impact on determining the potential success rate for future gene-directed therapy. Studies that focus only on structures or function of outer retinal layers, where current treatment options are targeted, may not be sufficient to predict the effectiveness of such treatments.
Supported by Foundation Fighting Blindness, Owings Mills, Maryland (GAF, EMS); Foundation Fighting Blindness Canada and Fonds de la Recherche en Santé Québec (FRSQ) (RKK); Grant Healthcare Foundation, Chicago, Illinois (GAF); NIH core grant EY01792 (UIC) and Grants EY016822 (EMS) and EY014275 (MS); a departmental grant from Research to Prevent Blindness (GAF, EMS); a Research to Prevent Blindness Senior Investigator Award (MS); and grants from the Department of Veterans' Administration (MS), the Howard Hughes Medical Institute (EMS), the Edel and Krieble Funds, the Ort Family Foundation, and the Foundation for Retinal Research (RKK).