A research adaptive optics nonlinear microscope has been used to visualize the structural changes in the corneal stroma after CXL treatment in bovine and porcine ex vivo eyes. The instrument works in backward configuration and provides both TPEF and SHG signals, which have been reported to be useful for noninvasive corneal imaging.
22 –31 We have shown structural alterations of CXL-treated corneas, which confirms the potential of this imaging modality for the analysis of the effects of this treatment.
In previous studies, the dynamic changes of corneal structures imaged with multiphoton microscopy were not reported. The dynamic changes occurring during the corneal collagen CXL treatment could be important to better understand the time course of the corneal response to the treatment. The use of a new multiphoton imaging modality based on tomographic sectioning has allowed a much faster recording of in-depth images and therefore tracking dynamic changes across the entire thickness of the sample. For this particular application, we were able to record a tomographic image of the entire cornea in approximately 2 minutes.
SHG microscopy has previously been used to detect differences in the organizational pattern of the stromal lamellae in pathologic corneas, but to our knowledge, this has not been used before to explore modifications in the stroma after CXL treatment.
The use of a backscattering microscope configuration allows for imaging of the intact eye. By applying nonlinear microscopy to CXL-treated cornea specimens in intact eyes, it has been shown that the stroma undergoes important morphologic changes. In particular, SHG signal, which targets the collagen structure, reveals changes in the organization and arrangement of the collagen bundles. On the other hand, TPEF provided quantitative, spatially resolved information of the penetration depth of riboflavin.
Unlike most previous studies, we were able to image the entire corneal thickness (up to 700 μm in control bovine eyes) in the backscattered direction (before and after CXL treatment) with comparatively lower incident energy. Technical improvements, such as the use of a photon-counting unit in the detection pathway together with the wavefront control,
32 –34 allowed us to record good quality images, even at the deepest corneal layers, to visualize the organization of the corneal stroma.
SHG images of bovine and porcine control corneas (
Figs. 2 and
3) show the particular packing of stromal lamellae recently reported.
28 Although this pattern was maintained for several hours in control eyes, it changed in CXL-treated corneas. Randomly distributed, flattened, and abnormal structures of collagen bundles in some localized areas are observed in post-CXL eyes. In particular, it has been shown (
Fig. 8) that morphologic changes in the corneal stroma are a result of the riboflavin-dextran itself, probably caused by dehydration produced by dextran 20% solution. In bovine eyes, with a thicker stroma containing thicker collagen bundles, the effects were more evident. These variations were only found at the anterior stroma, and the natural corneal fibrous structure seems to remain intact in the posterior stroma. However, these changes are local and difficult to generalize for the entire transversal corneal section given the particular 3D arrangement of the collagen fibrils and the limited scanned area available (up to 410 × 410 μm
2). The thickening of the collagen bundles after CXL have been reported before by Wollensak et al.
20 in rabbit eyes using biometric measurements of ultrathin corneal sections. The changes in the packing of the collagen fibers in cross-linked areas of the cornea, as opposed to the arrangement of nontreated areas, was recently reported by Steven et al.
35 using nonlinear microscopy on rabbit eyes.
Our results also show that a major effect in CXL treatment is the transient decrease of corneal thickness during and immediately after the treatment. Although Scheimpflug imaging measurements have recently reported similar results,
13 this is the first time that multiphoton microscopy has been used to quantify the effect in two and three spatial dimensions, to observe these spatially resolved changes across the corneal thickness and to track those changes as a function of time.
We have shown that corneal thinning is caused primarily by the riboflavin-dextran solution, which is hyperosmolar and consequently has a dehydrating effect on the stroma. The decrease in corneal thickness by instillation of riboflavin (and not the UVA radiation) immediately after treatment has been reported both in vitro in animal models
13 and intraoperatively in human patients.
36 There is wide evidence that the dehydrating properties of the dextran 20% solution in which the riboflavin is diluted are the cause for corneal thinning (Kling S et al.
IOVS 2010;51:ARVO E-Abstract 4628). To prevent this, hypo-osmolar solutions are currently under test.
37 The impact of other possible causes (such as dehydration by evaporation) is negligible. In fact, previous experiments on de-epithelized corneas (neither riboflavin nor CXL) did not show an increase of corneal thickness during the 40-minute period (if anything, corneas tended to slightly increase corneal thickness because of edematization).
13
For tomographic imaging, it has been shown that TPEF and SHG signals are complementary. Whereas TPEF signal comes from endothelial layer and from the keratocytes (the epithelium was removed), SHG is produced in the stroma. After CXL, the thickness reduction is observed in both TPEF and SHG tomography images. Both signals share the same cornea area, which indicates that the riboflavin penetrated into the entire corneal stroma. Moreover, the TPEF signal levels increased through the entire cornea because of the properties of riboflavin fluorescence. This rapid and even distribution of riboflavin through the entire cornea has recently been reported by Kampik et al.
31 on enucleated porcine eyes.
SHG imaging also revealed a progressive recovery of corneal thickness after CXL treatment. In the ex vivo eyes used here, the increase in corneal thickness was approximately 1 μm/second, but the initial thickness was never recovered.
Our results show that riboflavin-dextran solution causes relevant microstructural changes in the collagen. This is consistent with reports from X-ray diffraction
38 and electron microscopy
39 on corneas during dehydration that show that in a first stage of dehydration, corneal collagen fibrillar distance decreases as water is only released from the interfibrillar substance, and in a second stage, after dehydration exceeds a critical value, structural transformation of the collagen fibrils occurs with shrinkage and decrease in fibril diameter. Corneal biomechanical properties have been shown to be modulated by corneal hydration.
40 Furthermore, recent measurements of corneal deformation from inflation experiments show differences in the response of virgin corneas and corneas treated with dextran and riboflavin-dextran, suggesting changes in the interfibrillar distances but not a decrease in fibril diameter in the presence of riboflavin.
41 CXL has also been shown to increase the stiffening of normal corneas by means of induction of intra- and interfibril bonds,
4,9 and a similar mechanism may contribute to the observation of ectasia progression in keratoconic corneas.
The morphologic changes in the corneal stroma observed in the present study indicate an increase in the packing of the fibrils. This is consistent with a very recent study using SHG imaging on CXL corneas.
35 Although the conditions of measurement are different from ours, the study reports changes in the (XY) collagen distribution, from a wavelike to a more homogenous pattern. However, the authors did not address possible changes along the Z direction.
An open question of the present study is the possible extrapolation of the results on bovine and porcine corneas to human corneas. As recently shown, the collagen arrangement of the cornea strongly depends on the species.
33 Moreover, corneal thickness and its stiffness (porcine corneas are more elastic than human corneas) are also particular for each species. Although some differences might be expected for human corneas, biomechanical studies of CXL corneas from different species have provided comparable conclusions. Despite differences in the natural organization of collagen fibers in bovine and porcine corneas, we found organizational changes in both species after CXL. The decrease in corneal thickness has been also reported clinically in human patients (Ziebarth NM et al.
IOVS 2010;51:ARVO E-Abstract 4998). However, it is unlikely that the intraoperative thinning of the cornea caused by dehydration from dextran is related to redistribution of corneal thickness observed in human patients several months after surgery (in certain corneal locations). These long-term pachymetric changes are likely related to the biomechanical changes leading to symmetrization of the keratoconic corneas after the treatment.
42
In conclusion, we have shown that multiphoton microscopy is a powerful tool for the study of corneal collagen longitudinal changes after CXL treatment, shedding new light on the mechanisms underlying this treatment. Thanks to the sectioning capabilities of the SHG imaging, it has been possible to reconstruct the 3D arrangement of the entire corneal stroma and to observe the morphologic changes produced and the evolution of the corneal structure before, during, and after CXL treatment.
Presented in part at the annual meeting of the Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology, Fort Lauderdale, Florida, May 2010.
Supported by the “Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación,” Spain (Grants FIS2008-02065, FIS2009-06234-E, FIS2010-14926 and Consolider SAUUL CSD2007-00033), “Fundación Séneca,” Murcia, Spain (Grant 04524/GERM/06), and EUROHORCS-ESF (Grant EURYI-05-102-ES).