During the 1950s and 1960s, severe KCS was treated by transferring the parotid duct into the conjunctival sac.
18 –20 However, patients could not endure the gustatory epiphora, and this technique was discarded. To overcome this problem, several researchers tried to reduce the secretion of the operated parotid gland, but they failed to control the gustatory epiphora successfully without serious complications.
3,21 Keegan et al.
22 reported that intraglandular and periglandular injection of botulinum toxin might be useful to treat hyperlacrimation secondary to “crocodile tearing” or submandibular gland transplantation, but it was temporary. The saliva secretion from the parotid gland is predominantly regulated by the tympanic nerve. Since 1962, tympanic neurectomy has been successfully applied to reduce saliva secretion of the parotid gland in treating drooling, parotid fistula, Frey's syndrome, and chronic parotitis.
23 –26 It is a relatively mature technique for the otolaryngologists without serious complications.
13 We hypothesized that gustatory epiphora with parotid duct transfer to treat KCS might be controlled by resecting the tympanic nerve. Therefore, we designed a protocol of transferring the parotid duct into the inferior conjunctival fornix after tympanic neuroectomy to treat severe KCS in rabbits. Our results indicated that there was a significant decrease in the quantity of tear secretion in the operated eyes after chewing at all postoperative time points in the DTTN group compared with that in the DT group. The tear secretion from the operated eyes after chewing was much higher than secretion at rest in the DT group, while the tear secretion after chewing was similar to secretion at rest in the DTTN group. Therefore, gustatory epiphora after parotid duct transposition could be controlled by tympanic neuroectomy.
Bernard demonstrated that a denervated salivary gland maintained a basal secretion after an initial lag period (see review by Kumar et al.
27 ). Yu et al.
1 reported that the secretion of the denervated autotransplanted submandibular gland, which was attributed to basal secretion from the transplanted gland, could lubricate the ocular structures in patients with severe KCS. Geerling et al.
28 found that free submandibular autografts remained viable in the long term due to substantial survival of parasympathetic ganglia and sympathetic reinnervation in transplanted gland tissue. In the present study, tear secretion in the operated eyes with KCS alone significantly decreased within 3 months. The tear secretion from the operated eyes did not decrease after surgery in the DTTN group. Therefore, the denervated parotid gland did not lose the function of the secretion and maintained a basal secretion. In our study, tear secretion from the operated eyes did not significantly decrease at rest in the DTTN group compared with that in the DT group. As we know, saliva secretion is lower at rest in the parotid gland than in the submandibular gland, but significantly increases under stimulus. We speculated that the tympanic nerve predominantly regulates the saliva secretion of the parotid gland in response to stimulus, but not at rest. The mechanism of increased secretion at rest in the DTTN group at postoperative month 3 is not clear. Whether it was due to “paralytic” secretion needs further investigation. In the parotid gland on the operated side, the secretion granules decreased in the acinar cells 4 months after tympanic neuroectomy, the fatty tissues infiltrated in the lobes of the gland 6 months after surgery, whereas the morphology of the gland became normal 1 year after surgery, which suggested that no persistent atrophic changes would occur in the denervated parotid gland.
Kumar et al.,
27 in studying autologous submandibular gland transfer to treat KCS, found that the amylase activity of tears was significantly higher in successful cases than in unsuccessful cases. The authors considered that the amylase activity of tears could be an indicator of the successful transfer of submandibular gland. We found that the amylase activity of tears in the operated eyes was significantly higher at all time points after than before surgery in the DT and DTTN groups. The result indicates that the transferred parotid duct had not been obstructed and the amylase activity of tears could also be an indicator of successful parotid duct transposition.
In our study, goblet cell density measured at postoperative month 3 was lowest in the operated eyes of the KCS group compared with control eyes and the operated eyes of the DT group, especially significantly lower than that in the operated eyes of the DTTN group. Goblet cells synthesize, store, and secrete large gel-forming mucins that play an important role in keeping the tear film stable.
29 Goblet cell density is a critical variable that reflects the overall health of the ocular surface. Our results suggest that continuous secretion from the operated gland was helpful for the recovery of conjunctival goblet cells in KCS. However, mean corneal fluorescein and rose bengal staining scores were significantly higher in the operated than in the control eyes during the first three postoperative months in the three groups. The secretion of the parotid gland being purely serous and tenuous (it can stay in the ocular surface only for a relatively short time) may have led to abnormal staining of the cornea in the operated eyes in these two treatment groups.
The quality of saliva tears can be responsible for ocular surface changes. Several groups have performed autologous submandibular gland transfer to treat severe KCS successfully in the past 20 years.
1,4 –6,30 However, some problems were revealed after surgery. A low osmolality relative to tears may result in corneal epithelial microcystic edema in patients with excessive saliva tears.
31,32 An in vitro study showed that natural saliva from the submandibular gland had a severe cytoxic effect on corneal epithelial cells.
33 Its low osmolality was thought to be the major factor contributing to its toxicity. Zhu et al.
34 compared the quality of tears with that of saliva from the human parotid and submandibular glands. Their results demonstrated that the osmolality of saliva from the parotid gland was higher than that of the saliva from the submandibular gland, and the other results were consistent with those in a previous study.
31 Our previous study showed that the composition of saliva secreted by the denervated parotid gland with duct transposition was very close to that of normal tears.
35 However, the quality of saliva from the denervated parotid gland and its secretion mechanism must be further investigated.
In conclusion, gustatory epiphora could effectively be reduced after parotid duct transposition with tympanic neurectomy. However, saliva from the denervated parotid gland may be insufficient to warrant ocular surface health.
Supported by Natural Science Foundation of China Grants 30370102 and 81070847 and National Supporting Program for Science and Technology Grant 2007BAI18B11.
The authors would like to thank Bin Li and Liao-qing Li (Ophthalmological Institute, Beijing Tongren Hospital, Capital Medical University) for help with the histology.