TNF-α has an important role in experimental and clinical uveitis.
5,6 Neutralizing TNF-α systemically delayed disease onset and reduced tissue damage in EAU.
13,15,16,35 Our results of using different etanercept regimens in the EAU model suggest a primary role of TNF-α in the induction phase rather than in the efferent phase of EAU. In vitro experiments revealed enhanced antigen- and mitogen-induced proliferation of mature T cells by recombinant TNF
36 and abolished the proliferative activity of responder cells by anti-TNF antibodies in a human mixed lymphocyte reaction.
37 In accordance with these findings, the reduced histological EAU scores in our study were accompanied by a decreased antigen-specific proliferation of splenocytes and their production of proinflammatory cytokines. This is in line with a previous report in which the severity of EAU, antigen-specific lymphocyte proliferation, and the DTH response were reduced after systemic administration of polyclonal antibodies directed against TNF-α in the afferent phase. The authors suggested that neutralizing TNF-α inhibits the priming of antigen-specific effector T cells.
13
Macrophages activated in the proinflammatory conditions of IFN-γ or TNF-α at the immunization site play a pivotal role in generating antigen-specific effector T cells. It has been shown that these macrophages, once programmed from the peak of disease, may overcome immunoregulatory effects of TGF-β in the posterior chamber of the eye and that nitric oxide production was not influenced by ex vivo incubation with soluble TNF-receptor/IgG fusion protein.
38 From this perspective, we would not expect that the activation status of macrophages and the subsequent generation of effector T cells would be influenced by neutralizing TNF-α in the efferent phase. Thus, when the activation processes in the induction phase were completed, TNF-α blockade by etanercept was not sufficient to dampen ocular inflammatory responses in our experiments.
Clinical studies reported that, in part, uveitis patients could also be successfully treated with etanercept.
19,20 In contrast to EAU in B10.RIII mice, which is characterized by a monophasic, acute course,
14 periodic cycles of antigen priming can be assumed in uveitis patients, on which etanercept may act.
However, other studies have shown EAU improvement after treatment in the afferent and the efferent stages of EAU in a rat and mouse model by using a 55-kDa tumor necrosis factor receptor (TNFR1)-Ig fusion protein.
14–16 Data reported by Luger et al.
39 also indicated a strong reducing effect of neutralizing anti-TNF antibodies on EAU induced by adoptive transfer of uveitogenic Th1 cells.
39 In contrast, our present data demonstrate that TNF-α inhibition by etanercept did not ameliorate EAU in the adoptive transfer model, supporting the notion that etanercept acts more on the processes of T-cell priming and has only a minor impact on effector cells that had already been generated and exposed to the specific antigen.
Etanercept is a fusion protein of an antibody Fc fragment and the 75-kDa TNFR2. In contrast to the 55-kDa TNFR1, the TNFR2 was found to form relatively unstable complexes with soluble and transmembrane forms of TNF, which were characterized by high rates of association and dissociation. TNF that had dissociated from etanercept was bioactive.
17,40,41 Moreover, in contrast to anti-TNF antibodies, etanercept is still able to induce reverse signaling and thus does not completely impede monocyte reactivity to antigens.
42 This may explain the differences between our results and the findings of Dick et al.,
15,16 Hankey et al.,
14 and Luger et al.
39
Several reports have suggested an important role of resident ocular cells in the pathogenesis of intraocular inflammation as regards expression of molecules related to professional antigen-presentation properties, reactivation of invading autoreactive T cells, induction of TNF-α expression by these T cells, and local production of the TNF-α.
9,10,43–45 We therefore analyzed the effect of local TNF-α blockade at the site of inflammation by injecting etanercept intravitreally. Again, reduced EAU scores were observed after intravitreal etanercept treatment, but only in the afferent phase of disease. This is in line with results of a recently published study, in which local immunomodulation was achieved by the electrotransfer of a plasmid encoding a p55 TNF receptor/IgG1 fusion protein to the ciliary muscle. A shift toward a Th2-dominated effector response as deduced from the intraocular cytokine profile was suggested as a possible mode of action.
46 While several previous studies have indicated a protective role of activating the Th2 response and the associated cytokines on the course of EAU,
47–49 in IFN-γ-deficient mice such a deviant effector response in terms of Th1/Th2 balance has also been shown to be deleterious to the eye.
50 After intravitreal etanercept treatment, we observed an immune response exerting Th2 associated elements (splenic IFN-γ decreased, while IL-6 and IL-10 [slightly] increased), but without a shift to a prototypic Th2 response as the secretion of IL-4 was low. In contrast, after systemic etanercept treatment, an overall reduction of proinflammatory cytokines was detected. These results of varying cytokine production and different splenic proliferation responses indicate that the mechanisms of action underlying EAU improvement may differ between systemic and intravitreal anti–TNF-α treatment. The reduction of EAU scores after intraocular etanercept treatment does not seem to be primarily due to the backflow of etanercept into the conjunctiva after intravitreal injection, as EAU did not improve after subconjunctival treatment. An uptake study of FITC-labeled antisense oligonucleotides (ASON) (data not shown) indicated a rapid efflux of the agent to the regional draining lymph nodes (DLNs) after subconjunctival injection. Taking these observations together, a minor role of these DLNs in regulating EAU-mediated dynamics of inflammatory cells can be suggested under these experimental conditions.
Our data demonstrated a more potent effect for systemic etanercept treatment than for intravitreal treatment in reducing EAU severity. In a clinical study, patients with active uveitis had elevated TNF-α levels in sera and aqueous humor compared with control patients. The TNF-α serum levels were higher than in the aqueous humor and thus the authors concluded that systemic participation is greater than local participation of TNF-α in the pathogenesis of uveitis.
51
EAU in B10.RIII mice is characterized by an acute course of disease,
14 which may make it difficult to detect the efficacy of a therapeutic intervention, such as with etanercept. TNFR-IgG fusion proteins and antibodies directed against TNF-α operate by neutralizing TNF-α posttranslationally. We therefore assessed an alternative local treatment strategy with ASON targeting the messenger RNA of TNF-α and thus preventing TNF-α synthesis.
52 However, also local ASON injection had no ameliorating effect on EAU in both the afferent and the efferent phase (data not shown).
Several studies implicate a participation of intraocular TNF-α in the maintenance of immune privilege by inducing apoptosis of inflammatory cells infiltrating the eye.
53–56
Furthermore, TNF-α contributes to the immune privilege of the eye as it is involved in the induction of ACAID.
33 The induction of ACAID by intracameral injection of IRBP suppressed the development of IRBP-induced EAU in mice,
57 whereas in EAU-affected inflamed eyes, immune privilege is compromised.
58 Anti-TNF antibodies blocked the suppression of DTH when the antibody was coinjected with the antigen into the anterior chamber, suggesting that intraocular TNF-α is important in ACAID.
33 We analyzed whether TNF-α blockade had an impact on the induction of VCAID by injecting etanercept intravitreally. Compared with mice that received OVA intravitreally, the etanercept/OVA group showed an increased DTH. The notion of such an immunomodulation was supported by the fact that IL-10 expression was in contrast slightly reduced. IL-10 represents a key cytokine in the induction of ACAID.
59,60 Therefore, intraocular TNF-α possesses regulatory and inhibitory functions that may be impaired by intravitreal etanercept treatment. Correspondingly, the anti-inflammatory value of intravitreal treatment with other TNF-α inhibitors, such as infliximab or adalimumab, is controversial.
61,62
Taken together, etanercept treatment was more effective in ameliorating EAU in the afferent than in the efferent phase, when antigen-specific, uveitogenic T cells have already been generated. This suggests that TNF-α plays an important role predominantly in the induction phase of EAU, and that etanercept affects the generation and priming of uveitogenic effector T cells. Our data suggest that the mechanism of action underlying EAU improvement may be different for systemic and local etanercept treatment.