We determined the protective efficacy in a murine model of conjunctivitis of a fully human IgG1 MAb to PNAG against
S. pneumoniae or MRSA, as well as a MAb to
P. aeruginosa alginate against this Gram-negative pathogen. We chose to evaluate local and systemic passive therapy in the setting of conjunctivitis, as these are not only the most likely clinical applications for MAb immunotherapies, but it is unlikely that a clinical test of preventative, active immunization would be undertaken in this setting due to the unduly large number of individuals that would be needed for such an evaluation. We found that the MAb to PNAG given by either an IP or intra-conjunctival injection, or applied topically, reduced conjunctival pathology and bacterial counts in these tissues. As PNAG production is commonly detected amongst many pathogens that cause eye infections,
15 it is possible that passive administration of the human MAb to PNAG could provide an additional approach to treat many different microbial conjunctival infections.
We also tested a MAb to
P. aeruginosa alginate
29 in the conjunctivitis model to validate its efficacy and demonstrated its functional and protective capacity in this part of the ocular tissues. This MAb has been previously shown to mediate protective immunity to
P. aeruginosa keratitis,
25,31 and the evaluation here of its activity in the murine conjunctiva extends the potential utility of this reagent for use against
P. aeruginosa bacterial conjunctivitis.
It is well established that antibody to surface polysaccharides of Gram-positive bacteria require complement and phagocytic cells, most often PMN, as cofactors to mediate killing and protective immunity. However, the need for additional cellular immune effectors is less well appreciated. We found that the MAb to PNAG was unable to reduce bacterial burdens and tissue pathology in the murine conjunctiva in both lymphocyte-deficient RAG 1 KO mice, and in germ-free mice lacking a microbiome-matured immune system. These findings are consistent with our previous report
22 showing that the MAb to PNAG is only protective against
S. aureus corneal infections when both lymphocytes and a microbiome-induced set of effectors are present. We also noted that in control mice challenged with Gram-positive pathogens, lymphocyte-deficient RAG 1 KO mice had higher bacterial levels in the conjunctiva 48 hours postinfection compared with WT C57l/6 mice. Notably, pathology scores did not differ, perhaps reflecting a limitation of the murine conjunctivitis model to detect smaller differences or the need for longer or more detailed observations regarding conjunctival pathology and its relationship to microbial burdens. Additionally, differences in bacterial burdens between WT and germ-free C567Bl/6 mice were not significant at
P ≤ 0.05. Overall, we have established with these animal models an impact of lymphocyte effectors and microbiome-induced immunity to achieve maximal adaptive immunity in ocular tissues.
Both the MAb to PNAG and a vaccine composed of a synthetic oligosaccharide of pentameric glucosamine linked to a carrier protein, tetanus toxoid
15,32, are in phase 1 or phase 2 human clinical trials (ClinicalTrials.gov identifier NCT03222401 for the MAb, NCT02853617 for the vaccine), as is the MAb to
P. aeruginosa alginate (ClinicalTrials.gov identifier for phase 1 study, NCT02486770; for phase 2 study, NCT03027609). Thus, these reagents could be investigated in the near term for their efficacy in the setting of ocular infections, as infectious diseases are the fourth most common cause of preventable blindness in humans.
33 The MAbs, in particular, could be useful for prophylaxis in a setting of high risk for ocular infection, such as following eye trauma or individuals with recurrent infections, or as adjunctive chemotherapy along with standards of care for therapeutic interventions in established infections. Systemic and topical administration of the MAb has been effective in mice with keratitis
15,23,34 and, as shown here, conjunctivitis. Although the latter disease is much less sight-threatening, it is a costly disease to treat,
13 thus providing justification for clinically useful, cost-effective interventions. Notably, topical and intraconjunctival injections of small amounts of MAb were successful in reducing conjunctival bacterial burdens and disease, which could make the local use of small amounts of a MAb highly cost-effective.
In conclusion, we have found that systemic administration of antibody to PNAG prior to infection provided protection against S. pneumoniae and S. aureus conjunctivitis. Similarly, therapeutic administration of intraconjunctival or topical antibody postinfection was efficacious, situations mimicking that appropriate for treatment of an already infected conjunctiva. Along with antibody, lymphocytes and microbiome-induced immune system maturation were also required for maximal lowering of S. pneumoniae and S. aureus bacterial burdens and pathology. These findings support human studies to actually determine the utility of immunotherapeutic prevention or treatment of major microbial causes of eye infections targeting the broadly-expressed surface antigen, PNAG, a process that is now facilitated by testing of appropriate reagents in human phase 1 and 2 trials.