To our knowledge, this is the first study to analyze the effects of an ER stress inhibitor (4PBA) on the progression of DR symptoms in four different mouse models. This study focused on the assessment of three major morphologic hallmarks of DR: reduced microvessel density, increased acellular capillaries, and increased pericyte ghosts. We also performed a preliminary examination of ER stress–related protein expression. ER stress has been identified as a causal factor for atherosclerotic development in ApoE
−/− mice.
44–46 Increased levels of ER stress have been observed in chemical (STZ-injected ApoE
−/−) and genetic (ApoE
−/−:Ins2
+/Akita) mouse models of hyperglycemia.
47 Glucosamine, which is a product of glucose flux through the hexosamine pathway and an ER stress–inducing agent, has been linked to diabetic atherogenesis.
35,48 The inclusion of the GlcN-supplemented treatment group allowed for comparison of the effects of ER stress alone under normoglycemic conditions.
The decline in microvessel density from the optic disc to the peripheral retina seen across all groups, including control mice, is consistent with observations made in the healthy human retina.
49 However, it is uncertain if the decrease seen in ApoE
−/− mice is representative of healthy mice or if it is exacerbated by the ApoE
−/− genotype. Interestingly, hyperglycemic mice showed no difference in acellular capillary density compared to control mice. This is inconsistent with the findings from previous studies in which STZ-injected mice and ApoE
−/−:Ins2
+/Akita mice were observed to have significantly increased acellular capillary densities relative to wild-type controls.
42,50,51 Pericyte loss is believed to precede acellular capillary development, which may explain the presence of increased numbers of pericyte ghosts in the experimental groups without an increase in acellular capillaries.
10,52,53 It is also possible that the similarity in acellular capillary density between control mice and treatment groups is a result of the pathophysiology (dyslipidemia) of the ApoE
−/− control, which may contribute to increased acellular capillary development relative to wild-type (normolipidemic) controls used in other studies.
42,50,54 The protein kinase C pathway, which has been found to contribute to acellular capillary development, is upregulated in ApoE
−/− mice and could cause an increase in acellular capillaries in ApoE
−/− mice to the level of the experimental groups.
55–57 The ability of 4PBA to reduce acellular capillary density is consistent with previous studies.
19,58
Differences in pericyte ghost densities between controls and experimental groups, as well as between 4PBA and non-4PBA-treated mice within the same group, increased in significance moving outward from the optic disc. The trends observed with respect to pericyte ghost and microvessel vessel density in GlcN-supplemented mice are very similar to those in STZ-injected and ApoE
−/−:Ins2
+/Akita mice, suggesting that ER stress, even in the absence of hyperglycemia, may be a contributor to DR pathogenesis.
19,29,59,60
The UPR is an adaptive signal transduction pathway to maintain ER homeostasis.
61 The UPR is activated by three ER stress sensors: inositol requiring enzyme 1⍺, PKR-like ER kinase (PERK), and activating transcription factor 6⍺.
62 Under homeostatic conditions, these ER stress sensors remain inactivate through association with a chaperone called binding immunoglobulin protein (BiP), also known as GRP78.
62 However, as misfolded proteins accumulate in the ER, BiP dissociates from the UPR sensors and binds to the hydrophobic domains of the misfolded proteins with a greater affinity, allowing for activation of downstream signaling pathways by the UPR sensors.
63–65 The adaptive UPR functions to restore homeostasis and mitigate ER stress, but when this fails, a proapoptotic response is initiated.
66 Under chronic ER stress, PERK upregulates the transcription of GADD153/CHOP, which inhibits the expression of the antiapoptotic (BCL-2) to induce cell death.
67,68 Levels of GRP78 (adaptive UPR) and CHOP (apoptotic UPR) were measured in the retinas of mice in each of the experimental groups. These markers indicate the initiation of two key steps in the ER stress pathway.
Li et al.
19 have noted increased GRP78 expression in the retinas of ApoE
−/−:Ins2
+/Akita mice, relative to controls. This is consistent with observation of increased GRP78 expression in the midretinal region in this study. 4PBA did not have any significant effect on GRP78 expression, except for the increase seen in control mice in the midregion. This, taken with the microvessel data showing that 4PBA further increased microvessel density in control mice, suggests that 4PBA may have a toxic effect in ApoE
−/− mice. 4PBA is a histone deacetylase inhibitor that has been shown to induce the expression of certain ER chaperones, including GRP78.
60,69,70 The extent of GRP78 induction has been found to be positively correlated with the amount of histone acetylation.
69 Previous reports have shown that 4PBA increases GRP78 expression in control groups of some cell types.
71,72
CHOP expression was increased in ApoE
−/−:Ins2
+/Akita mice relative to controls in the mid- and peripheral retina, which is consistent with the literature.
73 There was a trend toward increased CHOP expression in STZ-injected and GlcN-treated mice. 4PBA reduced CHOP expression in the peripheral retina but not in other regions of the experimental groups. This suggests that there are regional differences in the response to hyperglycemic conditions, including a heightened ER stress response further outward from the optic disc, as well as increased susceptibility to ER stress–inhibiting agents. There are multiple mechanisms that may account for the diverse effects of 4PBA in various retinal regions and treatment groups. 4PBA is a nonspecific chemical chaperone and a histone deacetylase inhibitor.
73,74 4PBA has a variety of uses, including as a treatment for urea cycle disorders because of its ability to act as a nitrogen sink.
75 Additional applications of 4PBA are currently being studied in areas including cancer, hemoglobinopathies, cystic fibrosis, and motor neuron diseases.
74 In relation to diabetes, 4PBA has been found to improve diabetic encephalopathy and nephropathy, muscle atrophy, inflammation, and β-cell apoptosis.
58,76–81 The reduction in CHOP expression with 4PBA suggests that 4PBA effectively alleviates ER stress to suppress the proapoptotic UPR.
68,82
Overall, this work characterizes the pathologic changes associated with DR in three different mouse models of diabetic atherosclerosis. The results show that hyperglycemia is sufficient to promote DR. Furthermore, a downstream metabolite of glucose (glucosamine) can promote DR in the absence of changes in glucose and insulin levels. Finally, the findings from this study support a role for ER stress in the development of DR and suggest that alleviation of ER stress can protect against DR progression.