Open Access
Retina  |   November 2024
Three-Dimensional Choroidal Vessels Assessment in Age-Related Macular Degeneration
Author Affiliations & Notes
  • Elham Sadeghi
    Department of Ophthalmology, University of Pittsburgh, School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States
  • Nicola Valsecchi
    Department of Ophthalmology, University of Pittsburgh, School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States
    Ophthalmology Unit, Dipartimento di Scienze Mediche e Chirurgiche, Alma Mater Studiorum University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy
    IRCCS Azienda Ospedaliero-Universitaria di Bologna, Bologna, Italy
  • Mohammed Nasar Ibrahim
    Department of Ophthalmology, University of Pittsburgh, School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States
  • Katherine Du
    Department of Ophthalmology, University of Pittsburgh, School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States
  • Elli Davis
    Temple university, School of medicine, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States
  • Sandeep Chandra Bollepalli
    Department of Ophthalmology, University of Pittsburgh, School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States
  • Kiran Kumar Vupparaboina
    Department of Ophthalmology, University of Pittsburgh, School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States
  • Jose Alain Sahel
    Department of Ophthalmology, University of Pittsburgh, School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States
  • Jay Chhablani
    Department of Ophthalmology, University of Pittsburgh, School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States
    https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1772-3558
  • Correspondence: Jay Chhablani, Department of Ophthalmology, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; 200 Lothrop Street, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA; [email protected]
Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science November 2024, Vol.65, 39. doi:https://doi.org/10.1167/iovs.65.13.39
  • Views
  • PDF
  • Share
  • Tools
    • Alerts
      ×
      This feature is available to authenticated users only.
      Sign In or Create an Account ×
    • Get Citation

      Elham Sadeghi, Nicola Valsecchi, Mohammed Nasar Ibrahim, Katherine Du, Elli Davis, Sandeep Chandra Bollepalli, Kiran Kumar Vupparaboina, Jose Alain Sahel, Jay Chhablani; Three-Dimensional Choroidal Vessels Assessment in Age-Related Macular Degeneration. Invest. Ophthalmol. Vis. Sci. 2024;65(13):39. https://doi.org/10.1167/iovs.65.13.39.

      Download citation file:


      © ARVO (1962-2015); The Authors (2016-present)

      ×
  • Supplements
Abstract

Purpose: To compare the choroidal vasculature in eyes with early- and intermediate-stage age-related macular degeneration (dAMD) and healthy using a novel three-dimensional algorithm.

Methods: Patients with dAMD and healthy controls underwent clinical examinations and swept-source optical coherence tomography scans (PlexElite-9000 device) centered on the fovea. Scans with quality scores >6 were included. Eyes with any signs of neovascular AMD or geographic atrophy were excluded. The choroidal layer was segmented using ResUNet model and volumetric smoothing. Phansalkar thresholding was used to binarize the choroidal vasculature. The three-dimensional maps were divided into five sectors. The three largest vessels in each sector were measured to determine the mean choroidal vessel diameter (MChVD) and inter-vessel distance (IVD). Volumetric choroidal thickness (ChT) and vascularity index (CVI) were also calculated.

Results: This retrospective cross-sectional study analyzed 60 eyes from 45 dAMD patients (27 early-stage, 33 intermediate-stage) and 26 eyes from 16 healthy controls. The average MChVD was increased in dAMD eyes compared to healthy eyes (239.559 ± 47.058 µm vs. 197.873 ± 49.047 µm, P < 0.001). The average MChVD in each sector increased significantly in eyes with dAMD (P < 0.05). The average IVD was increased significantly in dAMD eyes compared to healthy eyes (234.128 ± 69.537 µm vs. 179.914 ± 49.995 µm, P < 0.001). The average IVD in each sector was significantly increased in eyes with dAMD (P < 0.05). Average ChT and CVI in dAMD were reduced compared to healthy eyes (P < 0.05).

Conclusions: Eyes with dAMD demonstrated increased MChVD and IVD and decreased ChT and CVI, possibly related to smaller-vessel atrophy and larger-vessel dilation.

Age-related macular degeneration (AMD) is a progressive disease in old age, which starts with drusen and pigmentary changes in the early and intermediate stages and leads to advanced AMD with significant atrophy or new vessel formation affecting central vision.1 The underlying causes of the disease remain elusive. Critical neural, structural, and vascular layers are hypothesized to deteriorate, resulting in inflammation, cell autophagy, proteolysis, and lipid accumulation. These changes are thought to stem from abnormal reactions to oxidative stress and inflammation and the triggering of the complement systems.2,3 Retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) and photoreceptors may have a role in AMD pathogenesis.4 Additionally, choroidal microvasculature aging significantly contributes to the pathogenesis, resulting in increased vascular resistance and a decrease in choriocapillaris density.2,3 
Optical coherence tomography (OCT) is the preferred imaging method for the diagnosis and follow-up of AMD, because it can show the presence of drusens, atrophic changes, and retinal and choroidal thicknesses.5 Furthermore, the development of en-face optical coherence tomography (OCT) scans offers rapid spatial mapping of choroidal vessels, enabling a comprehensive analysis of morphological alterations within a single view. Choroidal vascularity index (CVI), which can be generated from volume maps, is a new OCT biomarker used to illustrate choroidal blood vessels in AMD. It is calculated as the ratio of the choroidal vessel volume to the total choroidal volume.6,7 Research suggests that a decreased ratio of the small-vessel layer thickness to the total choroidal thickness, along with an increased thickness of Haller's layer, is associated with a higher incidence of AMD.8 Recently it has been shown that choroidal enlarged vessels in the Haller's layer might play a role in the pathogenesis of the disease because they may have a specific distribution pattern of vessel arrangement.9 Several studies indicated the Haller layer changes in AMD.911 However, choroidal vessel analyses have been done using two-dimensional cross-sectional single or volumetric scans. Choroidal vessels are organized in a more intricate and three-dimensional structure. Thus the three-dimensional (3D) evaluation will provide accurate quantitative analyses. 
To address these limitations, our team has formulated a semi-automated algorithm to reconstruct a 3D choroidal vasculature image. Additionally, we have established a method for measuring the diameter of vessels across various segments of the choroid in 3D. Consequently, the primary aim of our current research is to evaluate the largest choroidal vessels that are within the Haller layer in eyes with dry AMD, in comparison to age-matched healthy subjects, by using this innovative 3D approach, and the secondary aim is to compare choroidal vessels between early and intermediate-stage AMD. 
Material and Methods
Patient Selection
In this retrospective, cross-sectional study, we included the eyes of patients with early and intermediate AMD and healthy age and gender-matched controls. The study was conducted at the Medical Retina and Vitreoretinal Surgery, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, from January 2023 to January 2024. The study adhered to the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki. A “waiver of informed consent” was obtained considering the retrospective nature of the study. 
We included patients >55 years old with confirmed diagnosis of early AMD, with small or medium-sized drusen with no pigmentary change, and intermediate-stage AMD, with large drusen with or without pigmentary change, based on the Bechman classification.12 Patients with ocular conditions like vitreoretinal diseases, uveitis, glaucoma, retinal vascular diseases, diabetic retinopathy, and high myopia were excluded from the study. Furthermore, individuals who had any ocular surgeries, except for uncomplicated cataract surgeries, were also excluded. Additionally, factors that affected the quality of OCT scans, such as ocular surface disorders, advanced cataracts, or vitreous opacities, were grounds for exclusion. Power analysis was used to determine the minimum sample size required for a study to detect an effect of a given size with a certain level of confidence. 
OCT Imaging Acquisition
Dilated images centered on the fovea were captured using the Plex Elite 9000 device (Carl Zeiss Meditec, Dublin, CA, USA) with an expanded field swept-source (SS-OCT) 12 × 12 mm scan with 100 kHz acquisition. The scan speed of this machine is up to 200,000 A-scans per second, the wavelength is 1060 nm, the scan depth is up to 6 mm in tissue, and the axial resolution is approximately 6.3 µm in tissue. The scan quality was assessed using the SS-OCT software's built-in scoring system, and only scans with scores of 6 or higher (highlighted in green) out of 10 were included in the analysis. SS-OCT scans were exported as eight-bit volumes, each consisting of 1024 B-scans with a resolution of 1024 × 1536. The multimodal imaging acquisitions were subsequently evaluated. An expert retina specialist classified AMD eyes into early and intermediate stages through examination or color fundus photography, following the Beckman classification criteria.12 
Automated Choroidal Vessel Segmentation
The outlined procedure involves a combination of automated and manual techniques aimed at measuring the 3D cross-sectional diameter of choroidal vessels. Our technique begins with the application of residual network-based encoder-decoder deep learning architecture (ResUnet) to delineate the choroid's boundaries within all the structural SS-OCT scans.13 The process of demarcating the choroid layer is centered on identifying the choroid inner boundary along the junction of the RPE layer and choriocapillaris, and the choroid outer boundary along with the choroidal-scleral junction. A deep learning model followed by a volumetric smoothing process was used for choroidal segmentation, and to avoid potential issues, we used a manual boundary correction. The deep learning model was explained in our previous research studies.1315 The accuracy of the choroidal boundaries of this algorithm, assessed in unpublished data, was 92.4% in dry AMD eyes, which increased to 100% after manual correction. 
The next step in our methodology is the choroidal vasculature segmentation from SS-OCT volumes. According to the challenges with OCT image acquisition, including artifacts such as speckle noise, retinal shadows, contrast fluctuations, volumetric misalignment of B-scans, and complex architecture and intensity characteristics of the choroidal vasculature, we implemented the Phansalkar thresholding method to facilitate the distinction between luminal and stromal areas.1618 
These factors make traditional intensity-based thresholding techniques unsuitable for precise vessel segmentation. To overcome this, we have implemented the Phansalkar thresholding method, a technique recently developed by our group. This method adaptively calculates the local threshold within each 16 × 16 pixel tile across the B-scans, enabling the distinction between luminal and stromal areas.16 Subsequently, we apply morphological post-processing to remove extraneous elements, resulting in a seamlessly constructed 3D model of the choroidal vasculature. 
We have developed two graphical user interfaces (GUIs) for automated and manual tasks within our proposed method. The first GUI is designed for precise extraction of 3D choroidal vasculature from OCT data, accepting raw SS-OCT volumes in either IMG or JPG formats, segmentation of choroid boundaries, and choroid vessel segmentation. The choroidal segmentation can be corrected manually if needed. As a preparatory step, ImageJ 1.51 s (National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD, USA) is used to create an optic disc mask that is used to obscure the choroidal vasculature at optic disc sites. Subsequently, the choroid vessel segmentation is conducted, and the 3D choroidal vasculature models are preserved for manual cross-sectional diameter measurements in the next step (Fig. 1). 
Figure 1.
 
Choroid layer boundary segmentation, automated choroidal vessel segmentation, and three-dimensional choroidal vessels. (A) SS-OCT scans from a cube scan of the right eye with an early-stage dry AMD patient. (B) Choroidal segmentation in the choroid inner boundary located at the junction of the RPE layer and choriocapillaris, and the choroid outer boundary situated at the choroidal-scleral junction. (C) Automated choroidal vessel segmentation. (D) The 3D 12 × 12 mm choroidal vessel map with a mask disc. All these steps are done with the first graphical user interface.
Figure 1.
 
Choroid layer boundary segmentation, automated choroidal vessel segmentation, and three-dimensional choroidal vessels. (A) SS-OCT scans from a cube scan of the right eye with an early-stage dry AMD patient. (B) Choroidal segmentation in the choroid inner boundary located at the junction of the RPE layer and choriocapillaris, and the choroid outer boundary situated at the choroidal-scleral junction. (C) Automated choroidal vessel segmentation. (D) The 3D 12 × 12 mm choroidal vessel map with a mask disc. All these steps are done with the first graphical user interface.
To start measuring choroidal thickness, CVI, cross-sectional vessels, and inter-vessel diameters, the datasets are imported into the second GUI, which allows the grader to select any volume. By selecting the center of the fovea in the RPE enface image, which is the center of the foveal avascular zone area in correlation with cross-sectional B scan, a 12 × 12 grid will be applied over the 3D choroidal vasculature, to show different sectors, including central, nasal, temporal, superior, and inferior. The central sector is a circle with a 4 mm diameter. As shown in Figure 2, selecting a point opens a window displaying the vasculature in a small, fixed-size view around that point. The grader can rotate the vasculature to obtain the best view of the vessels and perform measurements more accurately. Simultaneously, the cross-sectional diameter values are recorded in an Excel sheet for subsequent analysis (Fig. 2). 
Figure 2.
 
Various sectors including nasal (N), temporal (T), superior (S), inferior (I), and central (C) in a 3D choroidal vessel map. (A) The center of the fovea in the RPE en-face OCT. (B) Different sectors based on the center of the fovea. All these steps are done with the second graphical user interface.
Figure 2.
 
Various sectors including nasal (N), temporal (T), superior (S), inferior (I), and central (C) in a 3D choroidal vessel map. (A) The center of the fovea in the RPE en-face OCT. (B) Different sectors based on the center of the fovea. All these steps are done with the second graphical user interface.
Our algorithm effectively segmented the entire choroid. However, because of the absence of delineation and subsequent reconstruction of the choriocapillaris vessels, the 3D vessel reconstruction is confined to Sattler's and Haller's vessels. This study specifically concentrated on the largest vessels (>100 µm) within each sector, all of which were from the Haller layer.1921 
Assessment of Choroidal Vessel Diameter and Intervessel Distance
The analysis entailed the selection of the three largest vessels within each sector, with three measurements recorded for each vessel. Before the selection process, the images were rotated to obtain a comprehensive 3D perspective, facilitating the identification of the three largest vessels per sector. Subsequently, the vessels were oriented to allow for a meticulous assessment of their diameters. The cross-sectional diameter was measured from the outermost visible portions of each vessel, with three measurements taken for each vessel. The average of these nine measurements (three per vessel) was then analyzed to determine the average choroidal vessel diameter (MChVD) for each sector. We defined the IVD as the space separating the largest vessel (which we evaluated for the MChVD) from the closest non-collateral vessel within the same sector. The average of these nine measurements (three per vessel) was then analyzed to determine the average IVD for each sector (Fig. 3). 
Figure 3.
 
Assessment of MChVD and IVD in the inferior sector of the right eye in early- and intermediate-stage AMD. The three largest vessels from the inferior sector are labeled as 1, 2, and 3. (A) These vessels were then oriented for a detailed diameter assessment. The cross-sectional diameter was measured from the outermost visible portions of each vessel, with three measurements taken per vessel (blue border). The IVD was determined by measuring the distance between the largest selected vessel and the nearest independent vessel (green border). Vessel 1 is shown in B, vessel 2 in C, and vessel 3 in D. The mean of the nine diameters was calculated to represent the MChVD of the inferior sector, and the mean of the nine IVD measurements was calculated to represent the mean IVD in the inferior sector. Values are reported in micrometers. The same procedure is applied to E–H as an intermediate-stage AMD. Vessel 1 is shown in F, vessel 2 in G, and vessel 3 in H, and MChVD (blue border) and IVD (green border) are measured. All these steps are done with the second graphical user interface.
Figure 3.
 
Assessment of MChVD and IVD in the inferior sector of the right eye in early- and intermediate-stage AMD. The three largest vessels from the inferior sector are labeled as 1, 2, and 3. (A) These vessels were then oriented for a detailed diameter assessment. The cross-sectional diameter was measured from the outermost visible portions of each vessel, with three measurements taken per vessel (blue border). The IVD was determined by measuring the distance between the largest selected vessel and the nearest independent vessel (green border). Vessel 1 is shown in B, vessel 2 in C, and vessel 3 in D. The mean of the nine diameters was calculated to represent the MChVD of the inferior sector, and the mean of the nine IVD measurements was calculated to represent the mean IVD in the inferior sector. Values are reported in micrometers. The same procedure is applied to E–H as an intermediate-stage AMD. Vessel 1 is shown in F, vessel 2 in G, and vessel 3 in H, and MChVD (blue border) and IVD (green border) are measured. All these steps are done with the second graphical user interface.
To evaluate the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) test, two masked readers, blinded to the patient's details, performed measurements across all sectors for ten eyes (E.S., N.V.). The measurements taken by the first grader (E.S.) were used for the study analysis, whereas the second grader (N.V.) measurements were used to evaluate intergrader reliability. The choroidal thickness (ChT) and the CVI for the entire volume were determined using specialized automated software. 
Statistical Analysis
The assessment of data normality was conducted using the Shapiro–Wilk test, followed by the application of parametric tests. To evaluate the consistency between raters for image binarization, we used the absolute agreement model of the ICC. The ICC values were interpreted as follows: less than 0.5 indicated poor reliability, between 0.5 and 0.75 suggested moderate reliability, between 0.75 and 0.9 denoted good reliability, and values greater than 0.90 signified excellent reliability. For categorical data analysis, the χ2 test was used. Demographic data, ChT, CVI, mean MChVD, and IVD were compared across different groups using linear mixed models. These groups included early and intermediate stages of dry AMD versus age- and gender-matched healthy patients. We also compare these parameters between early AMD and intermediate AMD eyes and between healthy and early-stage AMD. A P value <0.05 was used to indicate statistical significance. All statistical analyses were conducted using IBM's Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) version 26. 
Results
Demographic Data
A total of 86 eyes of 61 individuals were included in our analysis (60 eyes of 45 AMD patients, and 26 eyes of 16 healthy age-gender-matched controls). Among the 45 patients in the AMD group, 15 exhibited bilateral dAMD, with both eyes included in the study. Of these, eight had bilateral early-stage AMD, and six had bilateral intermediate-stage AMD. One patient had early AMD in the right eye and intermediate-stage AMD in the left eye. In 11 patients with dAMD, only one eye was included because of low-quality OCT angiography (OCTA) in the other eye. In 19 patients, only one eye was included because of neovascular AMD in the other eye. Among these, four patients had early-stage AMD in the included eye, whereas 14 had intermediate-stage AMD. Among the 16 subjects in the healthy group, both eyes were included in 10 cases. However, for six subjects, only one eye was included because of poor-quality OCTA in the excluded eye. 
Overall, the mean age of patients was 75.40 ± 9.55 years, and 39 (63.90%) were females. No differences in age were observed between the two groups (76.48 ± 9.07 years in AMD vs. 72.37 ± 8.42 years in healthy patients, P = 0.140). Best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA) was diminished in AMD eyes compared to controls (0.150 ± 0.160 vs 0.016 ± 0.038 LogMAR, P < 0.001). Of all the dry AMD eyes, 27 (45.00%) were in the early stage, and 33 (55.00%) were in the intermediate stage. The mean BCVA was lower in intermediate AMD compared to early AMD (0.163 ± 0.169 vs. 0.096 ± 0.133 LogMAR, P = 0.022; Table 1). Assessment of ten eyes for ICC between two masked readers for measurements of MChVD and IVD showed a high degree of agreement across all sectors, with an ICC value of 0.887 and a confidence interval of 0.806 to 0.928. 
Table 1.
 
Demographic Data
Table 1.
 
Demographic Data
ICC in 3D Assessment
3D Assessment in AMD and Healthy Eyes
The average ChT was found to be significantly reduced in eyes with dry AMD when compared to the healthy group (210.809 ± 68.446 µm vs. 236.337 ± 62.734 µm, P < 0.001). The ChT in all sectors was lower in AMD eyes compared to the healthy group, as shown in Table 2
Table 2.
 
A Comparison of Choroidal Parameters Such as MChVD, IVD, ChT, and CVI
Table 2.
 
A Comparison of Choroidal Parameters Such as MChVD, IVD, ChT, and CVI
The average CVI showed a reduction in eyes with dry AMD relative to healthy eyes (0.368 ± 0.045 vs. 0.368 ± 0.042, P = 0.002). The CVI values were consistently lower in the AMD group in all the sectors, and the values are shown in Table 2
The average MChVD in all the sectors (three vessels per sector) was increased in AMD eyes compared to healthy eyes (239.559 ± 47.058 vs. 197.873 ± 49.047 µm, P < 0.001). By evaluating the MChVD in each sector, we found that eyes with dry AMD exhibited an increase in MChVD in each sector, with a statistically significant difference compared to healthy eyes. 
The average IVD was significantly increased in AMD eyes compared to healthy eyes (234.128 ± 69.537 µm vs. 179.914 ± 49.995 µm, P < 0.001). By analyzing the mean IVD in each sector, we found a significant increase in eyes with dry AMD in comparison to healthy eyes in each sector (Table 2). A representative example is shown in Figure 3
3D Assessment in Early Versus Intermediate AMD
Of all the dry AMD eyes, 27 (45.00%) were classified as early-stage, whereas 33 (55.00%) were defined as intermediate-stage. The average ChT across all sectors was lower in the intermediate-stage AMD group compared to the early-stage group (215.606 ± 83.592 µm vs. 192.738 ± 51.142 µm, P = 0.411). On sector-by-sector analysis, the ChT was consistently lower in the intermediate-stage group, but the results were not statistically significant (P > 0.05). 
The average CVI across all sectors was found to be lower in eyes with intermediate-stage dry AMD compared to those in the early stage (0.367 ± 0.056 vs. 0.351 ± 0.044, P = 0.703). On sector-by-sector analysis, the CVI was consistently lower in the intermediate-stage group; however, these variations were not statistically significant (P > 0.05). 
The average MChVD for all sectors, considering three vessels per sector, revealed no significant distinction between the early and intermediate stages of dry AMD (early-stage: 232.874 ± 45.487 µm vs. intermediate-stage: 236.542 ± 50.006 µm, P = 0.255). Additionally, when examining each sector individually, the differences in MChVD remained statistically nonsignificant (P > 0.05). The average IVD of all the sectors did not show a significant difference between early and intermediate-stage AMD eyes (early stage: 240.870 ± 71.638 µm vs intermediate stage: 227.847 ± 63.664 µm, P = 0.169). Furthermore, when assessing the IVD within each sector, no significant differences were observed (P > 0.05) (Table 3). The comparison between healthy eyes and those with early AMD revealed a statistically significant increase in average MChVD (P = 0.003), particularly in the temporal (P = 0.002) and superior sectors (P < 0.001). Although the nasal, temporal, and central sectors exhibited a trend toward higher MChVD (P > 0.05), this was not statistically significant. Eyes with early-stage AMD demonstrated significantly higher IVD across all sectors (P < 0.05) and a trend toward lower ChT in all sectors (P > 0.05). Additionally, CVI showed a decreasing trend in eyes with early-stage AMD, with a statistically significant reduction in the nasal sector (P = 0.003) (Table 4). 
Table 3.
 
A Comparison of Choroidal Parameters Such as MChVD
Table 3.
 
A Comparison of Choroidal Parameters Such as MChVD
Table 4.
 
Comparison of Choroidal Parameters
Table 4.
 
Comparison of Choroidal Parameters
Discussion
By using an innovative 3D algorithm to evaluate choroidal vessels, our study found that the average MChVD was increased in dry AMD eyes compared to age-matched healthy eyes (P < 0.001). We showed that the average MChVD in each sector increased significantly in eyes with dry AMD (P < 0.05). Also, the results revealed that the mean IVD was significantly increased in dry AMD eyes compared to healthy eyes (P < 0.001). The average IVD in each sector was significantly increased in eyes with dry AMD (P < 0.05). Additionally, this study exhibited a reduction in average ChT in dry AMD compared to healthy eyes (P < 0.001) and a reduction in average ChT in eyes with dry AMD per each sector (P > 0.05). In comparing healthy and early-stage AMD, the eyes with early-stage AMD showed significantly higher MChVD and IVD (P > 0.05). Furthermore, we observed that the eyes at the intermediate stage of AMD showed reduced ChT and CVI in all sectors compared to those at the early stage, although statistical significance was not reached (P > 0.05). 
In our research, we implemented an advanced semi-automated algorithm designed to generate 3D visualizations of choroidal vessels. This innovative tool enabled us to accurately measure the diameters of these vessels and the distances between larger ones within a 3D framework. Consequently, we were able to conduct a comprehensive analysis of the choroidal vasculature, choroidal stroma, and their spatial dynamics in patients with early and intermediate stages of dry AMD. Prior research predominantly concentrated on analyzing choroidal biomarkers through OCT B-scan or volumetric reconstructions of the choroidal vasculature.22 Nevertheless, such methodologies fall short of delivering an exhaustive evaluation of the choroidal vasculature, including assessments of vessel diameters and IVD, which are uniquely ascertainable through 3D imaging techniques. Considering the variable depths, measurements obtained on two-dimensional imaging or en-face imaging are unreliable. Thus 3D analysis is essential for choroidal vessel analysis. 
The deterioration of choriocapillaris endothelial cells, RPE, and photoreceptors significantly contribute to AMD onset.4,23 Several studies indicated that a reduced ratio of the small-vessel layer's thickness to the choroid's average thickness, coupled with an increased thickness in Haller's layer, correlates with a greater incidence of AMD. 8 An en-face SS-OCT study by Baek et al.24 has found large choroidal vessels in 46% of cases with neovascular AMD, highlighting that morphological alterations extend beyond the choriocapillaris to the deeper choroidal vessels. These findings include a general thinning of the choroid with localized dilations in the deeper vessels. Furthermore, Sacconi et al.25 have identified potential circulatory pattern anomalies within Haller's layer in patients with dry AMD including laterally diagonal and reticular patterns, suggesting that abnormalities in the choroidal enlarged vessels may contribute to the disease's development. Consistent with prior research, our findings indicate an enlargement of the MChVD in eyes affected by dry AMD. These findings suggest that the pathogenesis of AMD from RPE, photoreceptor, and choriocapillaris extends its impact to the larger vessels of the choroid as well. Besides vessel diameter changes, changes in the choroidal interstitial stroma were histologically reported in eyes affected by AMD; In the disease progression, there is a sequential degeneration of the choroidal vasculature with subsequent stromal and fibrous tissue replacement.26,27 Our study observed an increase in the IVD in a 3D perspective, potentially suggesting that this biomarker might serve as a measure of the choroidal stroma situated among the large Haller's vessels, which may be attributed to smaller vessel degeneration and replacement with fibrosis and stroma. The observed reduction in ChT, coupled with an increase in MChVD and IVD, substantiate this discussion. 
CVI, as a novel parameter derived from OCT imaging showing a ratio of choroidal vessel volume to choroidal stroma, has been suggested to effectively measure choroidal structural alterations in various disorders, including AMD.28 A decline in CVI may indicate a secondary consequence of AMD or implicate choroidal ischemia in its pathogenesis.28 It is associated with different degrees of AMD progression risk, and it could be used as a biomarker of AMD progression.27 It is typically measured using a single two-dimensional OCT B-scan with binarization.6 The assessment of CVI in macular diseases has enriched our comprehension of potential structural alterations. In our analysis, we utilized three-dimensional imaging to evaluate CVI, providing a more detailed assessment. Our study demonstrated a trend of decreasing CVI among AMD patients compared to healthy controls and also when comparing intermediate-stage AMD to early-stage AMD across all evaluated sectors. Although the CVI changes from the early to intermediate stage were not significant, the trend of regression shows slight changes during the disease progression. 
During the disease progression, there is a notable choroidal thinning and CVI reduction. These biomarkers are valuable for assessing the risk of disease progression and predicting visual acuity outcomes. Additionally, the possibility of medium-sized vessels being replaced with fibrotic tissue may lead to compensatory dilation of the remaining vessels, evidenced by the increase in the diameter of large vessels. Alterations in choroidal vessel diameter and intervessel distance could thus serve as novel biomarkers for AMD progression. 
The limitations of our study are its retrospective nature and small sample size. Although we considered power analysis, more sample size may help to explore more details. Because of the retrospective cross-sectional design of our study, tracking the progressive changes in AMD patients over time, which is vital for understanding the evolution of choroidal changes, was not feasible. Another limitation of our study is the absence of axial length correction for OCTA scales. Although the use of angular units, such as arcminutes or degrees, would have been preferable to linear units, we were unable to implement this adjustment.29,30 Our algorithm successfully segmented the whole choroid; however, because of the lack of delineation and subsequent reconstruction of the choriocapillaris vessels, the 3D vessel reconstruction is limited to Sattler's and Haller's vessels. This study specifically focused on the largest vessel (>100 µm) within each sector, all of which were from the Haller layer.1921 To gain deeper insights into choroidal changes in advanced AMD cases, including those with geographic atrophy and neovascular AMD, additional research examining 3D images is essential, which is our team's future goal. 
Conclusions
In the eyes affected by dry AMD, there was a notable increase in average MChVD and IVD in all the sectors. Concurrently, there was a significant reduction in the average CVI and ChT when compared to healthy eyes. Additionally, eyes in the intermediate-stages AMD showed a trend of lower ChT and CVI values than those in the early stage. Overall, the application of three-dimensional choroidal imaging presents a unique noninvasive approach for investigating choroidal changes in dry AMD and other eye diseases and may potentially enhance our grasp of the underlying mechanisms driving their pathogenesis. Future research could enable automated measurements of vessel diameters and IVD, as well as assessments of the positioning and orientation of choroidal vessels in 3D images in all stages of AMD. These measurements could serve as imaging markers of disease progression, helping to identify patients at risk. 
Acknowledgments
Supported by NIH CORE Grant P30 EY08098 to the Department of Ophthalmology, the Eye and Ear Foundation of Pittsburgh, and an unrestricted grant from Research to Prevent Blindness, New York, NY. 
Disclosure: E. Sadeghi, None; N. Valsecchi, None; M.N. Ibrahim, None; K. Du, None; E. Davis, None; S.C. Bollepalli, NetraMind Innovations (I); K.K. Vupparaboina, NetraMind Innovations (I); J.A. Sahel, NetraMind Innovations (I), Pixium Vision (I), GenSight Biologics (I), Sparing Vision (I), Prophesee (I), Chronolife (I); J. Chhablani, NetraMind Innovations (O); Allergan (C), Novartis (C), Salutaris (C), OD-OS (C), Erasca (C), B&L (C), Iveric Bio (C), Ocular Therapeutics (I), AcuViz (I), Abbvie (I), Springer (R), Elsevier (R) 
References
Shome I, Thathapudi NC, Aramati BM, Kowtharapu BS, Jangamreddy JR. Stages, pathogenesis, clinical management and advancements in therapies of age-related macular degeneration. Int Ophthalmol. 2023; 43: 3891–3909. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Fleckenstein M, Schmitz-Valckenberg S, Chakravarthy U. Age-related macular degeneration: a review. JAMA. 2024; 331: 147–157. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Garcia-Garcia J, Usategui-Martin R, Sanabria MR, Fernandez-Perez E, Telleria JJ, Coco-Martin RM. Pathophysiology of age-related macular degeneration: implications for treatment. Ophthalmic Res. 2022; 65: 615–636. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Nowak JZ . Age-related macular degeneration (AMD): pathogenesis and therapy. Pharmacol Rep. 2006; 58: 353. [PubMed]
Vallino V, Berni A, Coletto A, et al. Structural OCT and OCT angiography biomarkers associated with the development and progression of geographic atrophy in AMD. Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol. 2024: 1–6.
Agrawal R, Ding J, Sen P, et al. Exploring choroidal angioarchitecture in health and disease using choroidal vascularity index. Prog Retinal Eye Res. 2020; 77: 100829. [CrossRef]
Corbelli E, Sacconi R, Battista M, et al. Choroidal vascularity index in eyes with central macular atrophy secondary to age-related macular degeneration and Stargardt disease. Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol. 2022; 260: 1525–1534. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Zhao J, Wang YX, Zhang Q, Wei WB, Xu L, Jonas JB. Macular choroidal small-vessel layer, Sattler's layer and Haller's layer thicknesses: the Beijing Eye Study. Sci Rep. 2018; 8(1): 4411. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Sacconi R, Cicinelli MV, Borrelli E, et al. Haller's vessels patterns in non-neovascular age-related macular degeneration. Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol. 2020; 258: 2163–2171. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Kim S, Lee H, Chung H, Kim HC. Choroidal neovascularization and Haller vessel morphology associated with vision and treatment number after 1 year in age-related macular degeneration. Korean J Ophthalmol. 2021; 35: 397–409. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Hacker V, Reiter GS, Schranz M, et al. Impact of large choroidal vessels on choriocapillaris flow deficit analyses in optical coherence tomography angiography. PloS One. 2021; 16(8): e0254955. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Ferris FL, III, Wilkinson CP, Bird A, et al. Clinical classification of age-related macular degeneration. Ophthalmology. 2013; 120: 844–851. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Arora S, Singh SR, Rosario B, et al. Three-dimensional choroidal contour mapping in healthy population. Sci Rep. 2024; 14(1): 6210. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Vupparaboina KK, Selvam A, Suthaharan S, et al. Automated choroid layer segmentation based on wide-field SS-OCT images using deep residual encoder-decoder architecture. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2021; 62: 2162–2162.
Ibrahim MN, Bashar SB, Rasheed MA, et al. Volumetric quantification of choroid and Haller's sublayer using OCT scans: an accurate and unified approach based on stratified smoothing. Comput Med Imaging Graph. 2022; 99: 102086.
Ibrahim M, Bollepalli SC, Selvam A, et al. Accurate detection of 3D choroidal vasculature using swept-source OCT volumetric scans based on Phansalkar thresholding. In: 2023 IEEE EMBS International Conference on Biomedical and Health Informatics (BHI). IEEE. 2023.
Agrawal R, Seen S, Vaishnavi S, et al. Choroidal vascularity index using swept-source and spectral-domain optical coherence tomography: a comparative study. Ophthalmic Surg Lasers Imaging Retina. 2019; 50(2): e26–e32. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Vupparaboina KK, Richhariya A, Chhablani JK, Jana S. Optical coherence tomography imaging: automated binarization of choroid for stromal-luminal analysis. 2016 International Conference on Signal and Information Processing (IConSIP), 2016;1–5.
Shiihara H, Seen S, Vaishnavi S, et al. Quantification of vessels of Haller's layer based on en-face optical coherence tomography images. Retina. 2021; 41: 2148–2156. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Esmaeelpour M, Kajic V, Zabihian B, et al. Choroidal Haller's and Sattler's layer thickness measurement using 3-dimensional 1060-nm optical coherence tomography. PloS One. 2014; 9(6): e99690. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Singh SR, Vupparaboina KK, Goud A, Dansingani KK, Chhablani J. Choroidal imaging biomarkers. Surv Ophthalmol. 2019; 64: 312–333. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Breher K, Terry L, Bower T, Wahl S. Choroidal biomarkers: a repeatability and topographical comparison of choroidal thickness and choroidal vascularity index in healthy eyes. Transl Vis Sci Technol. 2020; 9(11): 8–8. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Scholfield C, McGeown J, Curtis T. Cellular physiology of retinal and choroidal arteriolar smooth muscle cells. Microcirculation. 2007; 14: 11–24. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Baek J, Lee JH, Jung BJ, Kook L, Lee WK. Morphologic features of large choroidal vessel layer: age-related macular degeneration, polypoidal choroidal vasculopathy, and central serous chorioretinopathy. Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol. 2018; 256: 2309–2317. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Sacconi R, Cicinelli MV, Borrelli E, et al. Haller's vessels patterns in non-neovascular age-related macular degeneration. Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol. 2020; 258: 2163–2171. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
McLeod DS, Grebe R, Bhutto I, Merges C, Baba T, Lutty GA. Relationship between RPE and choriocapillaris in age-related macular degeneration. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci. 2009; 50: 4982–4991. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Sacconi R, Vella G, Battista M, et al. Choroidal vascularity index in different cohorts of dry age-related macular degeneration. Transl Vis Sci Technol. 2021; 10(12): 26–26. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Wei X, Ting DS, Ng WY, et al. Choroidal vascularity index: a novel optical coherence tomography based parameter in patients with exudative age-related macular degeneration. Retina. 2017; 37: 1120–1125. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Linderman R, Salmon AE, Strampe M, Russillo M, Khan J, Carroll J. Assessing the accuracy of foveal avascular zone measurements using optical coherence tomography angiography: segmentation and scaling. Transl Vis Sci Technol. 2017; 6(3): 16. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Llanas S, Linderman RE, Chen FK, Carroll J. Assessing the use of incorrectly scaled optical coherence tomography angiography images in peer-reviewed studies: a systematic review. JAMA Ophthalmol. 2020; 138: 86–94. [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Figure 1.
 
Choroid layer boundary segmentation, automated choroidal vessel segmentation, and three-dimensional choroidal vessels. (A) SS-OCT scans from a cube scan of the right eye with an early-stage dry AMD patient. (B) Choroidal segmentation in the choroid inner boundary located at the junction of the RPE layer and choriocapillaris, and the choroid outer boundary situated at the choroidal-scleral junction. (C) Automated choroidal vessel segmentation. (D) The 3D 12 × 12 mm choroidal vessel map with a mask disc. All these steps are done with the first graphical user interface.
Figure 1.
 
Choroid layer boundary segmentation, automated choroidal vessel segmentation, and three-dimensional choroidal vessels. (A) SS-OCT scans from a cube scan of the right eye with an early-stage dry AMD patient. (B) Choroidal segmentation in the choroid inner boundary located at the junction of the RPE layer and choriocapillaris, and the choroid outer boundary situated at the choroidal-scleral junction. (C) Automated choroidal vessel segmentation. (D) The 3D 12 × 12 mm choroidal vessel map with a mask disc. All these steps are done with the first graphical user interface.
Figure 2.
 
Various sectors including nasal (N), temporal (T), superior (S), inferior (I), and central (C) in a 3D choroidal vessel map. (A) The center of the fovea in the RPE en-face OCT. (B) Different sectors based on the center of the fovea. All these steps are done with the second graphical user interface.
Figure 2.
 
Various sectors including nasal (N), temporal (T), superior (S), inferior (I), and central (C) in a 3D choroidal vessel map. (A) The center of the fovea in the RPE en-face OCT. (B) Different sectors based on the center of the fovea. All these steps are done with the second graphical user interface.
Figure 3.
 
Assessment of MChVD and IVD in the inferior sector of the right eye in early- and intermediate-stage AMD. The three largest vessels from the inferior sector are labeled as 1, 2, and 3. (A) These vessels were then oriented for a detailed diameter assessment. The cross-sectional diameter was measured from the outermost visible portions of each vessel, with three measurements taken per vessel (blue border). The IVD was determined by measuring the distance between the largest selected vessel and the nearest independent vessel (green border). Vessel 1 is shown in B, vessel 2 in C, and vessel 3 in D. The mean of the nine diameters was calculated to represent the MChVD of the inferior sector, and the mean of the nine IVD measurements was calculated to represent the mean IVD in the inferior sector. Values are reported in micrometers. The same procedure is applied to E–H as an intermediate-stage AMD. Vessel 1 is shown in F, vessel 2 in G, and vessel 3 in H, and MChVD (blue border) and IVD (green border) are measured. All these steps are done with the second graphical user interface.
Figure 3.
 
Assessment of MChVD and IVD in the inferior sector of the right eye in early- and intermediate-stage AMD. The three largest vessels from the inferior sector are labeled as 1, 2, and 3. (A) These vessels were then oriented for a detailed diameter assessment. The cross-sectional diameter was measured from the outermost visible portions of each vessel, with three measurements taken per vessel (blue border). The IVD was determined by measuring the distance between the largest selected vessel and the nearest independent vessel (green border). Vessel 1 is shown in B, vessel 2 in C, and vessel 3 in D. The mean of the nine diameters was calculated to represent the MChVD of the inferior sector, and the mean of the nine IVD measurements was calculated to represent the mean IVD in the inferior sector. Values are reported in micrometers. The same procedure is applied to E–H as an intermediate-stage AMD. Vessel 1 is shown in F, vessel 2 in G, and vessel 3 in H, and MChVD (blue border) and IVD (green border) are measured. All these steps are done with the second graphical user interface.
Table 1.
 
Demographic Data
Table 1.
 
Demographic Data
Table 2.
 
A Comparison of Choroidal Parameters Such as MChVD, IVD, ChT, and CVI
Table 2.
 
A Comparison of Choroidal Parameters Such as MChVD, IVD, ChT, and CVI
Table 3.
 
A Comparison of Choroidal Parameters Such as MChVD
Table 3.
 
A Comparison of Choroidal Parameters Such as MChVD
Table 4.
 
Comparison of Choroidal Parameters
Table 4.
 
Comparison of Choroidal Parameters
×
×

This PDF is available to Subscribers Only

Sign in or purchase a subscription to access this content. ×

You must be signed into an individual account to use this feature.

×